Fugitive Emissions Examples: Which Leaks Count in Scope 1?
A synthetic editorial scene shows a technician beside refrigeration equipment, with connected gauges, hoses and a clipboard. No legible gas quantity, measured leak rate, customer identifier or emissions result is visible.
Diagram text description
Fugitive emissions examples include refrigerant escaping from a cooling system, greenhouse-gas fire suppressant released during a discharge, SF₆ lost from electrical equipment and methane leaking from controlled gas or waste systems. The common feature is a greenhouse gas reaching the atmosphere from a source. A pipe, cylinder or equipment nameplate identifies a possible source; it does not prove how much gas escaped.
- Refrigeration and air conditioning: identify the actual refrigerant and the service or leak event.
- Fire suppression: distinguish agent stored, agent discharged and agent recovered.
- Electrical switchgear: investigate SF₆ stock and handling losses where that gas is used.
- Gas infrastructure and waste systems: trace methane through the equipment and its release pathways.
These examples are starting points for an inventory, not a list of sources every organisation must have. First establish the gas and the source boundary. Dust and an unspecified VOC release are not automatically greenhouse-gas emissions, and fuel burned in a boiler is a different mechanism. The cases below use operational control as the declared organisational approach; a different consolidation approach requires its own boundary assessment.
First decide whose source it is
A leak at a company site is not automatically the company’s Scope 1 emission. Under the operational-control approach used here, determine which organisation controls the source’s operation. The equipment register, lease, operating agreement and service arrangements can provide different pieces of that answer. A maintenance contractor visiting a company-controlled chiller does not necessarily take operational control of the chiller.
For a fictional cold store, the company sets the chiller’s operating policy and retains operational control while a contractor services it. A qualifying greenhouse-gas release from that equipment is assessed as the company’s direct Scope 1 source. Record the gas, release period and evidence for the quantity. The same physical equipment serviced by the same contractor could have a different reporting treatment if the actual control arrangement changed.
Identify the greenhouse gas, release event and reporting period. If the source lies within the company boundary under its declared consolidation approach, assess the direct Scope 1 release. Otherwise assess the relevant other inventory route; do not adopt the other operator’s leak as the company’s direct source.
Diagram text description
Compare a rented office supplied by a landlord-controlled central cooling plant. The tenant should not adopt every refrigerant loss at that plant as its own direct emission simply because cooling reaches its premises. Assess purchased energy and any other relevant value-chain treatment separately under the applicable boundary. Obtain the lease and plant-operation facts before deciding.
Ownership can be relevant, but apply the selected consolidation approach consistently rather than alternating between title and operational control to obtain a preferred result. Retain the decisive contract provision or operating record with the source. If the arrangement is unclear, keep that classification open and assign the evidence request to the asset or property owner.
Refrigeration and air-conditioning leaks
A refrigeration system contains an installed charge of gas. That charge can remain in service, move into recovery equipment or escape during operation, maintenance or removal. HFC refrigerants are important examples, but “refrigerant” is a use, not a single chemical identity. Obtain the refrigerant designation or blend composition before choosing the emissions treatment.
The equipment record should connect the installed charge with additions, recovered gas and maintenance events for the same period. A top-up can help identify a loss, but its interpretation depends on what happened to the system: new equipment may be filled, an existing unit may be repaired, or gas may be recovered and reused. A purchase invoice alone does not distinguish those movements.
Installed refrigerant is stock within the equipment. Additions move gas into that stock, and recovery removes gas into a separately recorded destination. An atmospheric release is a different outflow. Reconcile the period and service records rather than calling all stored or added gas an emission.
Diagram text description
For example, a contractor adds gas to a company-controlled freezer after a repair. The useful evidence is the freezer ID, gas type, mass added, reason for addition and any recovery record. A generic invoice reading “refrigeration service” leaves the quantity and gas unresolved. A nameplate gives the full proper charge or capacity, which is not necessarily the actual mass remaining after leakage.
Keep installation, operating service and retirement records separate enough to reconstruct the account. An end-of-life recovery transfer is not an atmospheric release just because it leaves the equipment. Likewise, manufacturing emissions from a purchased unit are not the same event as a refrigerant release during the reporting company’s own operations.
Fire-suppression gas releases
A fire-suppression system stores an agent until it is discharged, recovered, lost through a leak or removed during service. A controlled system containing a greenhouse-gas agent can therefore have direct releases even if it never experiences an accidental leak. A deliberate discharge to suppress a fire and an unintentional service loss need their own event records. The full system charge is not automatically the annual emitted mass.
Identify the agent from cylinder and system records, then link discharge reports, contractor service sheets, recovery quantities and changes in stored cylinders. Do not assume a suppressant has the same global warming potential or inventory treatment as a refrigerant. Inert gases and other agents require their actual substance-specific assessment rather than a generic “fire gas” factor.
The EPA guidance also distinguishes ozone-depleting CFCs, HCFCs and halons from the gases included in the main CO₂e inventory under its stated accounting framework. It describes separate memo reporting for those substances. This does not make them harmless or remove their separate management requirements; it means their inventory treatment cannot be inferred from the word “gas.”
If a contractor replaces an entire cylinder, request the old cylinder’s recovered contents and destination as well as the new fill. Without those records, the replacement invoice could represent a stock exchange rather than a complete discharge. The source record should state which event has actually been established.
SF6 escaping from electrical equipment
Some electrical equipment uses sulfur hexafluoride, SF₆, as an insulating or arc-interruption medium. It may be held in circuit breakers, gas-insulated switchgear and related equipment. The gas in a sealed system is stock. A release during operation, installation, maintenance or decommissioning is a different event that needs its own quantity basis.
For controlled equipment, preserve gas additions, recovered quantities, beginning and ending stock, and the equipment changes that explain them. Ask the operator for service and handling records rather than treating the installed capacity as a loss. If a utility controls the switchgear serving the site, the utility’s SF₆ release does not automatically become the customer’s Scope 1 emission. The boundary depends on the actual asset and operating arrangement, not merely where the electricity is consumed.
The equipment specification should confirm whether SF₆ is present at all. Similar-looking electrical equipment can use different insulation technologies. A photograph of a substation does not establish its gas type or a release. The same care applies to a purchase line marked only “insulating gas.”
Record an SF₆ source separately from each refrigerant or blend. A kilogram is a mass unit shared by many gases, but their climate-equivalent conversion factors differ. This examples guide does not assign one numerical GWP to every gas or claim a specific release from a particular switchgear design.
Methane leaking from gas infrastructure
Methane can escape from gas-handling equipment before the gas is burned. Valves, seals, pipe connections and storage are examples of places to investigate within a controlled gas system. The release mechanism differs from a boiler consuming fuel: escaping methane and combustion products are not interchangeable quantities or methods.
Consider a valve on a company-controlled process-gas line and a leak on a utility-operated supply pipeline. Establish the asset boundary, operator and reporting period for each. Inspection findings, event duration, gas composition and a suitable measurement or estimation method support quantification. A utility delivery bill may show purchased fuel, but it does not isolate the mass lost at a particular valve. Do not label the whole delivered quantity as leaked methane.
A leak-detection instrument can identify an event without necessarily measuring its total annual mass. Check what the instrument result represents: a concentration, an instantaneous rate or an integrated quantity. Converting a concentration alone into kilograms requires additional information and an appropriate method. Retain that distinction in the source record.
The practical decision is to separate source identification from the supported release estimate. A report of “gas smell near pipework” should prompt the relevant operational response and investigation, but it is not a completed greenhouse-gas calculation. Preserve the event evidence and use the source-specific method instead of inferring a release quantity from the repair cost.
Methane from waste and wastewater systems
Methane can be generated as organic material breaks down in landfills or wastewater systems. For a reporting organisation, the first boundary question is whether the relevant system is within its controlled operations. Sending waste to another operator’s treatment facility does not, by itself, make that facility’s methane the sender’s direct emission.
Trace generated gas through its actual paths. Some methane may be collected, then used in an engine or sent to a flare. Some may reach the atmosphere without capture, and captured gas may also escape before combustion. Capture is an intermediate movement, not another emitted quantity to add beside the same gas later burned or released.
Generated methane can be captured and then used or flared. Some gas may escape without capture, and captured gas can also leak before combustion. Apply the relevant waste-system method to these paths and combustion emissions separately. Do not add captured gas to emitted methane as if they were separate releases.
Diagram text description
A source-specific waste method may need generation, collection, destruction efficiency and other system information. An electricity meter on a gas engine does not alone quantify every methane release from the treatment system. Equally, a collection-system total should not be presented as the mass that escaped. Preserve the basis for each path and keep any unburned methane or combustion emissions on their applicable accounts.
Inventory terminology also matters. A methodology may classify part of a waste-system release as process emissions rather than as a fugitive subcategory. Document that choice and maintain a consistent boundary; changing the label does not eliminate a direct source. The useful question is which gas reached the atmosphere, through which mechanism, and how the chosen waste-system method accounts for it.
What is not a fugitive GHG example?
Start with the emitted substance and mechanism before calling a source “fugitive.” Similar-looking plumes, vents and equipment can represent different inventory activities. An emissions inventory becomes difficult to interpret if a general air-pollution list is copied directly into the greenhouse-gas register without those distinctions.
- Identify the substance. Establish the gas or blend rather than assuming dust or an unspecified VOC is a greenhouse gas.
- Identify combustion. Fuel burned in a controlled boiler is stationary combustion; methane lost before that combustion is a separate release pathway.
- Identify the process mechanism. A chemical reaction producing a gas is not a leak simply because gas exits the process.
- Establish the source boundary and quantity basis. Apply the selected organisational approach and an appropriate method to the actual activity.
A boiler stack, a leaking gas valve, a process reaction and a dusty loading bay therefore need different questions. The stack calls for combustion activity and factors. The valve calls for methane release evidence. The process needs its reaction or production method. Dust or a generic VOC label cannot be inserted into a CO₂e calculation without identifying a relevant greenhouse gas and its treatment.
These distinctions also prevent double counting. Do not calculate the same methane as both unburned gas and fully combusted fuel. If a source has several mechanisms, separate their activity records and explain the allocation. The categories describe the physical and accounting basis of the emissions; they are not interchangeable labels chosen after a total has already been calculated.
Find the underlying equipment evidence
An equipment register becomes useful when its asset ID connects the physical source with the records behind its estimate. Record the gas designation, installed capacity, actual-stock basis where available, service dates, additions, recovery destinations and inspection findings. A contractor’s documents should carry enough identification to join them to the correct equipment and reporting period.
| Field | Filled fictional equipment record |
|---|---|
| Asset and boundary | Chiller C-04, Meridian Cold Store, 2025 operational control |
| Gas identity | HFC-134a, supported by the fictional equipment and cylinder register |
| Equipment stock basis | Opening installed mass 30 kg; closing recorded mass 28 kg from the service account, not a nameplate reading |
| Additions | 6 kg installation fill and 5 kg service additions, linked to sheets SV-11 and SV-18 |
| Recovery | 10 kg removed and transferred to an external recovery vendor, note RV-07 |
| Release and inspection | 3 kg documented release in event records; inspection file IN-04 |
| Review question | Reconcile a separate 1 kg bulk-store difference before finalising the complete gas account |
Table 1, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.
Row 1
- Field
- Asset and boundary
- Filled fictional equipment record
- Chiller C-04, Meridian Cold Store, 2025 operational control
Row 2
- Field
- Gas identity
- Filled fictional equipment record
- HFC-134a, supported by the fictional equipment and cylinder register
Row 3
- Field
- Equipment stock basis
- Filled fictional equipment record
- Opening installed mass 30 kg; closing recorded mass 28 kg from the service account, not a nameplate reading
Row 4
- Field
- Additions
- Filled fictional equipment record
- 6 kg installation fill and 5 kg service additions, linked to sheets SV-11 and SV-18
Row 5
- Field
- Recovery
- Filled fictional equipment record
- 10 kg removed and transferred to an external recovery vendor, note RV-07
Row 6
- Field
- Release and inspection
- Filled fictional equipment record
- 3 kg documented release in event records; inspection file IN-04
Row 7
- Field
- Review question
- Filled fictional equipment record
- Reconcile a separate 1 kg bulk-store difference before finalising the complete gas account
The fictional asset ID joins gas identity and charge with the top-ups, service events, inspection and recovered transfer. Each record explains a different movement; the invoice and service sheet should not create two additions for the same event. The reviewer can trace the 3 kg documented release while keeping the 1 kg store query open. A revised service sheet should identify its earlier version and the period affected.
Ask for the record that resolves the actual gap. A supplier receipt establishes delivery; a recovery note establishes a destination; a physical count supports stored mass. None substitutes for all the others.
Do not count every purchased kilogram as a release
Fictional reconciliation: Meridian Cold Store tracks one gas, HFC-134a, across its bulk store and controlled chiller equipment for 2025. All quantities and record identifiers below are invented teaching data in kilograms of gas. This is a movement account with an unresolved difference, not a measured annual CO₂e total or a claim that every missing kilogram was emitted.
| Fictional gas-account entry | Mass and record | Meaning in the reconciliation |
|---|---|---|
| Opening bulk stock | 10 kg, count ST-01 | Gas already held in cylinders |
| Opening installed stock | 30 kg, equipment account EQ-01 | Gas already in equipment, separate from bulk stock |
| Purchases received | 20 kg, delivery PU-05 | Inward stock movement, not an emission |
| Total available | 10 + 30 + 20 = 60 kg | Opening stocks plus external receipts |
| Closing bulk stock | 18 kg, count ST-12 | Gas still held in cylinders |
| Closing installed stock | 28 kg, equipment account EQ-12 | Recorded actual-stock basis, not nominal equipment capacity |
| Recovered transfer out | 10 kg, vendor note RV-07 | Gas removed from equipment and sent outside the account; not also closing stock |
| Documented release | 3 kg, event records EV-02 and EV-03 | Recorded atmospheric loss in the fictional evidence |
| Accounted total | 18 + 28 + 10 + 3 = 59 kg | Known closing stocks and recorded outflows |
| Unresolved difference | 60 − 59 = 1 kg | Open reconciliation query, not a measured additional release |
Table 2, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.
Row 1
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Opening bulk stock
- Mass and record
- 10 kg, count ST-01
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Gas already held in cylinders
Row 2
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Opening installed stock
- Mass and record
- 30 kg, equipment account EQ-01
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Gas already in equipment, separate from bulk stock
Row 3
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Purchases received
- Mass and record
- 20 kg, delivery PU-05
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Inward stock movement, not an emission
Row 4
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Total available
- Mass and record
- 10 + 30 + 20 = 60 kg
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Opening stocks plus external receipts
Row 5
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Closing bulk stock
- Mass and record
- 18 kg, count ST-12
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Gas still held in cylinders
Row 6
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Closing installed stock
- Mass and record
- 28 kg, equipment account EQ-12
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Recorded actual-stock basis, not nominal equipment capacity
Row 7
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Recovered transfer out
- Mass and record
- 10 kg, vendor note RV-07
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Gas removed from equipment and sent outside the account; not also closing stock
Row 8
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Documented release
- Mass and record
- 3 kg, event records EV-02 and EV-03
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Recorded atmospheric loss in the fictional evidence
Row 9
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Accounted total
- Mass and record
- 18 + 28 + 10 + 3 = 59 kg
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Known closing stocks and recorded outflows
Row 10
- Fictional gas-account entry
- Unresolved difference
- Mass and record
- 60 − 59 = 1 kg
- Meaning in the reconciliation
- Open reconciliation query, not a measured additional release
Opening bulk and equipment stocks plus purchases provide 60 kg in this fictional account. Closing stocks, recovered gas transferred out and documented releases account for 59 kg. The remaining 1 kg is unresolved. Purchased mass is 20 kg, whereas documented release is 3 kg; neither stock nor the unexplained difference is silently treated as a measured emission.
Diagram text description
Internal movements are not added as new receipts to this combined account. The service sheets record 6 kg installation fill and 5 kg top-ups from the bulk store. The equipment check is 30 + 6 + 5 − 10 − 3 = 28 kg. The store check gives 10 + 20 − 6 − 5 = 19 kg, while its closing count records 18 kg. That isolates the 1 kg difference for investigation rather than hiding it inside the purchase line.
The 20 kg purchased and the 3 kg documented release answer different questions. The 10 kg recovered transfer is counted once as an outflow, and the installed stocks are not treated as emitted. Before finalising the estimate, the stockkeeper checks cylinder tare weights, count timing and any missing transfer; the inventory owner reviews the equipment-stock reconstruction. If the inputs and flows are accepted as complete, the remaining difference needs the selected method’s treatment. Keep its uncertainty visible rather than silently assigning zero.
This example stops at gas mass. A real CO₂e conversion also requires the identified gas or blend and the applicable GWP basis. Apply a compatible conversion once; an input already expressed as CO₂e must not receive another GWP multiplier.
Handle missing or uncertain leak records
Missing leak records do not establish zero emissions. Start by separating what is known from what is missing: source existence, gas identity, installed charge, service quantities, period or release mechanism. Those gaps affect different parts of an estimate, and one cannot be repaired by choosing a lower factor.
The EPA guidance describes screening estimates based on equipment type and factors as preliminary and highly uncertain. They can help assess a source before stronger data are available, but they are not measurements of that particular machine. Where the source is significant, use a more suitable method supported by the necessary records. The guidance distinguishes a fuller material balance for organisations tracking stock from a simplified approach for appropriate equipment users serviced by contractors; its stated conditions matter.
For the fictional chiller account, retain the 1 kg difference as a named exception. The stockkeeper obtains the missing count or transfer evidence; the inventory owner decides the supportable estimate and explains the consequence for the release figure. If the refrigerant designation itself is missing, request it from the equipment or service supplier before selecting a gas-specific GWP. Do not borrow a neighbouring unit’s refrigerant as if it were confirmed.
Record the method, assumptions and data limitations with the result. A later repair can change future leakage, so a historical leak rate is not automatically the next year’s rate. Prioritise evidence improvements that address the largest uncertainty rather than implying that a precise-looking number has removed it.
A cross-sector classification checklist
Use the comparison to test a source’s gas, release mechanism and boundary together. These are real source types, but the rows do not assert that any particular customer has them. Operational control remains the declared approach for the company examples, and a different consolidation approach requires its own assessment.
| Source type and gas question | Direct-source assessment under the stated facts | Evidence or condition that changes treatment |
|---|---|---|
| Controlled refrigeration: identified HFC or blend | Assess operation and service releases in Scope 1 | Gas register, service mass and recovery records. A landlord-controlled plant is a different source-boundary case. |
| Controlled fire suppression: actual agent identified | Assess qualifying gas leaks or discharges; stored charge is not annual release | Agent identity, event and recovery records. Inert or ozone-depleting agents need their applicable separate treatment. |
| Electrical switchgear using SF₆ | Assess release from equipment inside the company boundary | Specification, operator agreement and gas account. Utility-controlled equipment does not become the customer’s direct source merely through electricity supply. |
| Methane from gas-handling assets | Separate gas escaping before combustion from fuel actually burned | Asset boundary, event and measurement or estimate. A utility-side pipe needs the other operator’s boundary assessment. |
| Controlled landfill or wastewater system | Assess methane release under the relevant waste-system method | Control and gas-path evidence. Outsourced treatment is not automatically the waste sender’s Scope 1; process versus fugitive classification must be consistent. |
| Dust or unspecified VOC pollution | No automatic fugitive-GHG classification or CO₂e quantity | Identify the substance and mechanism first. An air-pollution label alone is insufficient. |
Table 3, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.
Row 1
- Source type and gas question
- Controlled refrigeration: identified HFC or blend
- Direct-source assessment under the stated facts
- Assess operation and service releases in Scope 1
- Evidence or condition that changes treatment
- Gas register, service mass and recovery records. A landlord-controlled plant is a different source-boundary case.
Row 2
- Source type and gas question
- Controlled fire suppression: actual agent identified
- Direct-source assessment under the stated facts
- Assess qualifying gas leaks or discharges; stored charge is not annual release
- Evidence or condition that changes treatment
- Agent identity, event and recovery records. Inert or ozone-depleting agents need their applicable separate treatment.
Row 3
- Source type and gas question
- Electrical switchgear using SF₆
- Direct-source assessment under the stated facts
- Assess release from equipment inside the company boundary
- Evidence or condition that changes treatment
- Specification, operator agreement and gas account. Utility-controlled equipment does not become the customer’s direct source merely through electricity supply.
Row 4
- Source type and gas question
- Methane from gas-handling assets
- Direct-source assessment under the stated facts
- Separate gas escaping before combustion from fuel actually burned
- Evidence or condition that changes treatment
- Asset boundary, event and measurement or estimate. A utility-side pipe needs the other operator’s boundary assessment.
Row 5
- Source type and gas question
- Controlled landfill or wastewater system
- Direct-source assessment under the stated facts
- Assess methane release under the relevant waste-system method
- Evidence or condition that changes treatment
- Control and gas-path evidence. Outsourced treatment is not automatically the waste sender’s Scope 1; process versus fugitive classification must be consistent.
Row 6
- Source type and gas question
- Dust or unspecified VOC pollution
- Direct-source assessment under the stated facts
- No automatic fugitive-GHG classification or CO₂e quantity
- Evidence or condition that changes treatment
- Identify the substance and mechanism first. An air-pollution label alone is insufficient.
After classification, select the matching quantity method. A refrigerant movement account, an SF₆ equipment account and a waste-system methane method require different supporting data. Do not apply the most convenient method across every row. An open ownership question should stay visible beside the affected source, rather than being buried in a generic note beneath the company total.
Keep the source and its evidence connected
Keep one source record for each equipment or process account, with separate gas identities where needed. A useful register connects the asset, controlling entity, reporting period, quantity method, original evidence and current decision. This gives facilities staff a concrete request and lets the inventory preparer see what remains unresolved.
For the fictional C-04 chiller, link the service sheets, stock counts and external recovery note to the same gas account. The purchasing team owns the delivery record, the contractor supplies service quantities, and the stockkeeper resolves the cylinder count. The inventory owner records the estimate and its uncertainty. Those roles need coordination, but their records should retain their individual meanings rather than becoming interchangeable attachments.
When equipment changes hands or a contract changes, preserve the date and reassess which organisation includes the source. When a record is corrected, keep the earlier reference and explain the effect on the reporting period. A new invoice should not overwrite the reason an earlier estimate was made.
This organisation of evidence supports the next decision: whether the source is classified, whether its quantity can be estimated and which missing record matters most. Keep any unresolved condition attached to that source so it can be followed through to a documented outcome.
Use examples to start a source inventory
Start a source inventory with the equipment and processes actually present, then identify the gas and release pathway for each. Establish the organisational boundary before adding a direct emission, and distinguish stored mass, transfers, recovered gas and atmospheric loss. That sequence makes the examples useful without pretending every possible source exists at every site.
The next task depends on the gap. An unclear landlord or utility arrangement needs a boundary assessment. A chiller with incomplete service data needs a source-record request and an appropriate estimation method. A completed gas-mass account can move to Scope 1 quantification with the correct gas and conversion basis. A management plan then assigns the recurring controls and evidence owners.
The fictional reconciliation demonstrates why a purchase is not a release and why an unexplained difference must remain visible. Use it to frame the questions for your own records, not as a replacement for those records. A source inventory should leave the next preparer able to follow the classification, reproduce the supported estimate and see the specific uncertainty still to resolve.
Scope 1: direct emissions
