Evidence & claims
Carbon & recognition guidance
Make the scope of every carbon result and recognition badge as clear as the result itself.
State what was measured
When sharing a result, identify the product or project, quantity or functional unit, calculation date, data version, method and included stages. State important assumptions and exclusions. A factory-gate or FOB figure does not include every downstream stage. A delivered result must name its agreed destination and transport scope.
Use CO₂e for greenhouse gases expressed as carbon dioxide equivalent. Avoid switching between carbon, CO₂ and CO₂e where it would change the meaning of the number.
Distinguish the level of evidence
| Description | What it means | What it does not mean |
|---|---|---|
| Calculated | A result produced from the recorded inputs and method. | An independent audit or verified result. |
| Evidence reviewed | Supporting information reviewed within a stated scope. | Every facility, product or lifecycle stage has been independently assured. |
| Independently verified | An identified independent party assessed the stated subject, method, period and scope. | Verification of other products, later versions or a whole company unless expressly included. |
| ISO/GHG service | A commissioned study or inventory states the applicable standard and deliverables. | An ISO certification simply because the software was used. |
Comparisons and improvements
A percentage improvement needs a documented baseline and a comparable calculation: the same product function, unit, boundary and method, or a clearly explained adjustment. State the comparison period and evidence. Do not suggest that a lower per-unit result necessarily means lower total organisational emissions.
Examples of precise wording
| Prefer a scoped statement | Avoid the unsupported inference |
|---|---|
| “Calculated at 4.2 kg CO₂e per unit, factory-gate boundary, product version/date shown in the linked report.” | “This product creates no carbon.” |
| “Supporting data reviewed for the materials and manufacturing stages listed in the record.” | “Everything about this product is independently verified.” |
| “Credits representing X tonnes were retired under reference Y for the stated project allocation.” | “Buying credits removed the emissions generated by this order.” |
| “CarbonLoop Gold distributor recognition for the activity period and criteria in the validation record.” | “Our whole business and every product are certified carbon neutral.” |
| “The comparable footprint decreased by X% against the stated baseline and method.” | “Our organisation’s total emissions fell by X%” when only a per-unit product comparison was measured. |
These examples illustrate clearer presentation; the factual claim still needs evidence and a review of the law where it will be used. Do not copy the example numbers into a real claim.
Keep footprint and credit information separate
Show the calculated footprint separately from any carbon credit activity. If credits are purchased or retired, identify what they represent, the quantity, project/standard, retirement reference, date and allocation. A purchase receipt alone may not demonstrate retirement. Do not allocate the same retired units to multiple claims.
Do not describe credit retirement as removing or reducing the emissions generated by a product or order. EU consumer-facing rules applying from 27 September 2026 prohibit offset-based claims that a product has a neutral, reduced or positive greenhouse-gas impact. Other markets also require substantiated, non-misleading claims. Explain remaining emissions, exclusions and credit activity separately; do not use broad “zero emissions”, “carbon neutral” or “carbon free” wording as a shortcut. Recognition is not permission to make an unsupported environmental claim.
Use the correct badge and record
- Use only the badge issued to the named product, company or organisation.
- Preserve the logo, shape, role, level and validation link; do not upgrade or redraw it to suggest a different award.
- Link the displayed badge to the dedicated CarbonLoop recognition record so visitors can check its subject, level, scope and status.
- Keep product recognition separate from supplier company, distributor company and partner organisation recognition.
- Check the record’s period and current status. Correct or remove a claim when its basis changes, expires or is withdrawn.
Product Bronze is the automatic basic modelled-estimate status and requires no CarbonLoop review. It is not independently verified. Higher product levels and supplier, distributor and partner recognition require their relevant assessment and approval; example artwork is not a self-issued award or a downloadable credential. Independent evidence is required where the level calls for it. CarbonLoop programme recognition must not be described as independent certification unless an identified independent body actually issued that certification.
What a validation record should show
- A unique record identifier and the legal/trading name of the recognised subject.
- Whether the subject is a particular product/version, supplier company, distributor company or partner organisation.
- The level, applicable criteria version, assessment date and any validity/review date.
- The calculation unit, boundary, reporting period and product/project scope relevant to the recognition.
- The evidence level and assessor/verifier identity or role where disclosure is appropriate.
- Current status: active, under review, suspended, expired or withdrawn, with a non-confidential explanation where needed.
- A way to report an error and the last material record update.
The validation link is intended to let a website visitor check the credential without downloading an award. Do not publish source documents, staff details, private customer orders or factory-sensitive data simply because a badge record is viewable. A record example is not evidence that the issuance and validation system is already operational.
Application, assessment and issue
The applicant should select the correct track, identify the products or organisation, submit the listed earning evidence and declare material assumptions or gaps. An assessment checks the relevant thresholds, date range, duplicates and scope. A system calculation alone cannot satisfy a requirement for independent evidence.
For a product, match the SKU, material/manufacturing version and calculation boundary to the evidence. For a supplier company, record the eligible catalogue and denominator used to calculate coverage. For a distributor company, assess measurable platform projects, product calculations, reports, credit evidence and activity periods; do not claim a percentage of the distributor’s total external business when that denominator is unknown. For a partner, use the programme’s defined active-organisation and sustained-activity evidence.
If information is missing, explain the gap and allow a response rather than issuing a higher level on assumption. Product Bronze starts without review. For higher product levels and company or partner recognition, issue artwork only after the relevant approval and link it to the record. Payment for a subscription or review does not itself purchase a recognition level. The earning thresholds on the recognition page are not changed by this guidance. They are private programme thresholds, not statutory environmental-performance standards. Data assurance, verified improvement, participation and credit retirement are distinct claims.
Review, expiry and material changes
The proposed company/organisation recognition policy is a 12-month validity period from issue, subject to the programme criteria and any shorter period stated on the record. Reassessment should use the current applicable evidence window; lifetime use is not implied. Product evidence remains tied to the stated version and boundary and needs reassessment after a material change, even before a scheduled review.
- Notify the programme team when materials, manufacturing site, energy assumptions, packaging, route, quantity basis or verification scope change enough to affect the claim.
- Recalculate and review evidence when a change makes the previous result unreliable. Do not carry an old badge automatically onto a materially different product.
- Keep the previous version/date visible where needed to interpret historical reports; distinguish it from the current result.
- If a badge expires or is suspended/withdrawn, stop using it as a current active credential. A historical reference must clearly show its past period and status.
- Renewal is an evidence review, not automatic progression to a higher level. A lower supported level may be appropriate if current evidence no longer meets the previous criteria.
Corrections and questions
If a result, badge or claim appears wrong, provide the page or record link and a description through the contact page. The team should review the evidence and record any correction or status change. Example recognition records remain examples and do not prove that a real award has been issued.
Correction, suspension and appeal
A material data error, unsupported evidence, expired verification or misleading badge use may require correction, temporary suspension or withdrawal. Give the holder the reason and relevant evidence summary, an opportunity to respond where safe, and the steps needed to restore a valid status. An urgent suspension may be necessary to prevent an active misleading claim, with review afterwards.
The proposed process allows an appeal within 30 days and review by someone not responsible for the original decision where practicable. Acknowledge within five business days and aim for a reasoned response or progress update within 15 business days after the necessary evidence is available. Correct the record and notify affected parties where an error is confirmed. Keep personal and confidential evidence out of the public explanation.
Further guidance
Environmental claims should be specific and supported by evidence. The ACCC environmental claims guidance and its guidance on credits explain relevant principles for Australian claims. Other markets have their own requirements; confirm those that apply to your claim. EU consumer-facing sustainability labels require a qualifying certification scheme or public-authority basis under Directive (EU) 2024/825. Independent footprint verification is not, by itself, independent monitoring of the recognition scheme. CarbonLoop eligibility review must not be presented as independent scheme certification. Public badge classification, independent scheme governance and market-specific use remain subject to legal review; this description does not establish that those requirements have been met. This guidance does not itself certify compliance.
