Synthetic editorial scene of a commercial facility and electricity infrastructure beside unbranded energy-work documents at dusk
Location vs Market Based Scope 2: Explain the Difference in One Electricity Bill
Diagram text description

Original synthetic editorial photograph. A clearly synthetic commercial facility, power infrastructure and energy-work documents show the setting without claiming a measured result. Spatial grouping, branching and direction carry the explanation; short labels name only evidenced concepts.

An office consumes 100,000 kWh. Its electricity bill does not change when the accountant calculates a location-based total and a market-based total. The methods assign emissions to the same consumption using different evidence, so two different results can both be valid. They are alternatives for reporting that activity, not two quantities to add.

Location-based accounting uses an appropriate grid-average factor. Market-based accounting uses eligible contractual information and the applicable factor hierarchy, including treatment of any uncovered electricity. Buying a renewable product changes neither the meter reading nor, by itself, the physical generation supplying that building.

The worked example below follows a fictional office through both calculations, then changes its consumption and instrument coverage separately. That separation makes the figures useful: an energy manager can identify demand changes, procurement can inspect the contractual allocation, and a reader can see what caused a lower reported number. All numerical factors are invented teaching values; the method rules and evidence requirements must be applied to real sources before using a result.

What purchased energy belongs in Scope 2?

Scope 2 concerns indirect emissions from purchased or acquired electricity, steam, heating and cooling consumed by the reporting company. The power station may be outside the company's operational boundary, but the purchased energy belongs in its inventory under the Scope 2 accounting rules. A facility's own fuel combustion generally raises a different Scope 1 question; buying the resulting heat from another operator raises a Scope 2 question.

Begin with actual consumption by energy type, site and reporting period. Check meters, invoices, landlord allocations or other records, and identify estimates separately. An electricity contract cannot correct a consumption figure assigned to the wrong site or year. Also identify the grid or market from which the purchased energy is drawn. The method used to assign emissions is the next decision, not a replacement for activity data.

Start with the energy arrangement, before selecting factors.
Start with the energy arrangement, before selecting factors.
Diagram text description

Branches classify accounting perspective, not quantities to add. Purchased energy and own combustion differ. Electricity instruments do not automatically represent purchased heat or cooling.

Steam, heat and cooling deserve explicit treatment because electricity certificates do not automatically cover them. The GHG Protocol Guidance describes both location-based and market-based accounting for Scope 2 purchased energy, but available instruments and factors can differ by energy type and market. Record which energy stream a claimed instrument actually represents before applying it.

The location-based result: what the grid supplies

The location-based method asks what emissions are associated with the energy system supplying the place of consumption. For electricity, a company multiplies consumed units by an appropriate average generation emissions factor for the relevant grid and period, applying the standard's factor-selection rules. It is a geographically grounded view, not a claim about which generator sent individual electrons to the meter.

Select a grid region that matches the facility, rather than a convenient national figure if a more appropriate regional factor is available. Keep the factor year, unit and source with the calculation. If the facility consumed 10,000 kWh, the activity record is the same under both methods; the selected factor changes. A grid-average factor may include renewable generation already in the mix, but it cannot be replaced by a private certificate merely because the company bought one.

This method helps a reader understand exposure to the local energy system. A reduction may follow lower consumption, a changed grid factor, or a move to a different site. Those are not equivalent operational achievements, so explain which element changed between reporting periods.

The market-based result: what a qualifying contract supports

The market-based method asks what emissions a company may attribute to its electricity purchases using qualifying contractual instruments. Depending on the market, evidence might include an energy-attribute certificate, a supplier-specific product, a power-purchase arrangement or an applicable residual-mix factor. The GHG Protocol sets quality criteria, including credible claims to the attributes, appropriate market boundaries and vintage.

Buying something called “green power” is not enough. Identify the specific instrument and the amount of consumed energy it covers. Establish who owns the environmental attributes, whether they were retired or cancelled for the claimant, whether another buyer can make the same claim, and whether timing and market boundaries fit the consumption. If an instrument covers only part of the load, the rest still needs an eligible factor under the standard's hierarchy.

One load supports two separately calculated reporting views.
One load supports two separately calculated reporting views.
Diagram text description

All factors are fictional. Location: 100000×0.40/1000=40 tonnes. Market: (60000×0+40000×0.50)/1000=20 tonnes. The two outcome boxes must not be added. Contract eligibility is assumed for the example.

This is an attribution method, not a physical trace of electricity into the building. A valid contractual figure can differ from the local grid average because it reflects a different accounting question. Use it to report a supported purchasing claim, and show the location-based figure alongside it when dual reporting is required.

Check the evidence behind renewable claims

Start an evidence check with the bill and the instrument, not with the advertised colour of the tariff. Match the reporting company's legal entity or beneficiary, facility or load, energy quantity, generation or contract period, market boundary and retirement record. Keep document identifiers and the party responsible for the claim. A certificate still held by a broker, or sold to a second buyer, cannot support an exclusive claim by the first buyer.

Check the GHG Protocol's Scope 2 quality criteria before assigning an emission factor. A supplier statement can be helpful, but ask what generation sources and attributes are included and whether the supplier has accounted for certificates sold away. A power-purchase agreement may deliver energy, environmental attributes, both or neither to the reporting entity under its terms. The contract label alone does not decide the accounting.

If evidence is incomplete, do not force a zero-emission entry. Mark the gap, use the appropriate fallback factor under the method hierarchy, and retain the commercial document for review. The consequence of weak evidence is not simply a failed audit: it can change the inventory total and the wording of external renewable-electricity claims.

For the fictional office, the purchase file contains a 60,000-kWh instrument but the accountant initially enters 60,000 MWh. The beneficiary and period could be correct while this unit error makes coverage a thousand times too large. Reconcile the instrument quantity to the 100-MWh consumption before assigning a factor. A valid certificate is not permission to allocate more attributes than the company holds.

Reconcile coverage in the same energy unit.
Reconcile coverage in the same energy unit.
Diagram text description

100000 kWh is 100 MWh. The illustration allocates 60 MWh and leaves 40 MWh. Eligibility requires beneficiary, vintage, market and exclusive attributes; arithmetic does not establish those conditions.

A second check concerns scope. Suppose a contract covers the office but a warehouse belongs to a different purchasing entity. Copying the office's instrument into the warehouse workbook creates a beneficiary or allocation problem, not a mathematical one. Resolve the contractual entitlement and quantity allocation first. The same instrument must not be claimed twice merely because both sites share a brand.

Where the residual mix enters the calculation

A residual mix represents electricity attributes left after specifically claimed contractual instruments have been removed from a market's supply mix. It helps avoid assigning the same renewable attributes both to a certificate buyer and to customers without those certificates. The relevant residual-mix factor is used where available and appropriate under the market-based factor hierarchy.

The residual mix is not necessarily the ordinary grid average. If renewable attributes have been sold separately, an unclaimed consumer's market-based factor may differ from the location-based regional average. That difference can feel counterintuitive until the two allocation systems are kept separate. A company should record the factor's market, year and publisher, and should not invent a residual-mix value when an authoritative one is unavailable.

Residual attributes and the physical grid average answer different questions.
Residual attributes and the physical grid average answer different questions.
Diagram text description

The fork is an allocation concept, not measured electricity flow. The residual factor is not obtained by subtracting an arbitrary amount from a grid factor; use an appropriate published source and hierarchy.

For uncovered electricity, follow the Guidance's hierarchy and document why each preferred option is unavailable before moving to a fallback. This is especially important for a multi-site company: one country's residual mix or supplier product cannot be applied globally. A factor file should make the choice reproducible for each site and reporting year.

Surplus instruments do not imply negative uncovered load. If the office consumes 100 MWh and holds 120 MWh of otherwise qualifying attributes, a calculation cannot assign minus twenty MWh to the residual line. Apply the programme's rules for the unused amount and the inventory's eligible coverage. The arithmetic control is simple: covered consumption plus uncovered consumption must reconcile to the included load. It does not decide whether banking, transfer or use in another period is permitted. Those remain instrument-specific questions rather than assumptions to hide inside a spreadsheet formula.

A hypothetical side-by-side electricity example

For example, consider a fictional office that used 100,000 kWh of electricity in one year. Suppose the applicable grid-average factor is 0.40 kg CO₂e per kWh. Its illustrative location-based result is 40,000 kg CO₂e. The exact factor is invented solely to demonstrate the arithmetic; it must not be reused as a real-world regional factor.

Now suppose the company has qualifying, exclusively claimed instruments covering 60,000 kWh at an illustrative factor of 0.00 kg CO₂e per kWh, while the remaining 40,000 kWh uses an eligible residual-mix factor of 0.50 kg CO₂e per kWh. Its illustrative market-based result is 20,000 kg CO₂e. The 60,000-kWh claim depends on the instruments satisfying the quality criteria; a receipt for a generic green tariff would not establish that by itself.

The two totals differ by 20,000 kg CO₂e, but the organisation did not consume less electricity in this example. The comparison isolates a contractual allocation choice from physical consumption. In a real inventory, include the source factors, instrument identifiers, retirement evidence, period and any other energy streams before approving either figure.

The complete arithmetic can be displayed without hiding the uncovered remainder:

Table 1: scroll horizontally if needed.

Calculation line Electricity Illustrative factor Calculated emissions
Location-based, entire office 100,000 kWh 0.40 kg CO2e/kWh 40,000 kg CO2e
Market-based, qualifying coverage 60,000 kWh 0.00 kg CO2e/kWh 0 kg CO2e
Market-based, uncovered remainder 40,000 kWh 0.50 kg CO2e/kWh 20,000 kg CO2e

Add the covered and uncovered contributions within the market-based method.
Add the covered and uncovered contributions within the market-based method.
Diagram text description

The multiplication uses kWh and fictional kg CO2e/kWh factors. Contributions share the same boundary and are non-overlapping. Divide by 1000 kg/tonne. Do not add the separate 40-tonne location-based total.

Add the two market-based lines to obtain 20,000 kg CO2e, then divide kilograms by 1,000 to express 20 tonnes. The location-based calculation separately gives 40 tonnes. The zero in the covered line is an explicit scenario assumption for eligible instruments with that generation-emissions factor, not a claim that every renewable purchase has no life-cycle emissions. These Scope 2 figures do not complete a life-cycle assessment of the electricity system.

Now reduce consumption to 90,000 kWh while retaining eligible coverage for 60,000 kWh and holding both factors fixed. Location-based emissions become 90,000 × 0.40 = 36,000 kg CO2e. Market-based emissions become 60,000 × 0 + 30,000 × 0.50 = 15,000 kg CO2e. Consumption fell by ten percent, while the two reported changes are four and five tonnes respectively. Different factor assignments explain that difference; it is not evidence of two separate physical savings to combine.

A demand change affects both illustrative totals differently.
A demand change affects both illustrative totals differently.
Diagram text description

LB means location-based and MB market-based. At 90000 kWh, LB=90000×.40/1000=36t; MB=(90000−60000)×.50/1000=15t. These are alternative reporting views, not two physical savings to sum.

In another scenario consumption remains 100,000 kWh but qualifying coverage rises to 80,000 kWh. The location-based result stays at 40 tonnes. The market-based result becomes 80,000 × 0 + 20,000 × 0.50 = 10,000 kg, or ten tonnes. This isolates procurement attribution under fixed assumptions. It does not prove additional generation, avoided grid emissions or a reduction in office demand.

Report the two totals without adding them

When dual reporting applies, present the location-based and market-based totals as two views of the same Scope 2 activity, not as separate emissions to add together. Adding 40 tonnes and 20 tonnes from the example would count the same 100,000 kWh twice. Nor should the smaller result quietly replace the larger one everywhere; readers need to know which method a claim or target uses.

Label tables and charts unambiguously. Show the consumption, factor sources, market-based instrument coverage and uncovered load. Where relevant, explain a change in method, factor, supplier or certificate quality compared with the previous period. A decrease in one method accompanied by no decrease in the other may be valid, but it should invite explanation rather than concealment.

For a company with several facilities, roll up like-with-like totals within each method. Keep site-level records so an auditor can trace a large change to its source. The disclosure should preserve the distinct role of each method even when management prefers one figure for a particular target.

Diagnose the change before choosing an action

The office now has three distinct stories. Lower demand changes measured consumption. Greater qualifying coverage changes the market-based assignment. A revised factor file changes the calculation even if both meter and contract remain the same. Combining these explanations into one percentage would make it harder to decide what worked.

Start the comparison with unchanged quantities and factors where that is appropriate. Then introduce the actual change being investigated. The example's reduced-demand case holds the coverage and factors fixed; its procurement case holds demand fixed. These are author-constructed sensitivities, not an official decomposition formula or proof of causal grid effects.

Table 2: scroll horizontally if needed.

Observed change First investigation What the result alone cannot establish
kWh falls Meter period, occupancy and operating activity That procurement caused the demand reduction
Contractual coverage rises Eligible volume, beneficiary and retirement That the building used less electricity
Factor changes Source year, method and geography That staff changed operations

Diagnose quantities separately from a source revision.
Diagnose quantities separately from a source revision.
Diagram text description

The two investigation branches are not exhaustive numerical attribution. They distinguish physical or contractual inputs from changed estimation, with the section table assigning the next practical question.

A factor revision may require recalculation of a comparison year under the inventory's policy. Keep that analytical decision separate from a claim about what happened at the site. An energy manager needs a stable consumption series; an accounting reviewer also needs to understand changes in attribution and estimation.

The practical response follows the driver. Investigate equipment schedules when demand rises unexpectedly. Resolve quantity or beneficiary mismatches when coverage changes. Examine source methodology when a published factor moves. The two totals become useful because they direct different questions, rather than competing to be the smaller number.

When only one Scope 2 method applies

Under the published 2015 GHG Protocol Scope 2 Guidance, a company whose operations are entirely in markets without product-specific or supplier-specific contractual data reports one location-based total. If any operation is in a market offering those instruments, the company reports both location-based and market-based totals for all its operations. The trigger is availability in the market, not whether the company bought renewable electricity.

For operations without qualifying contractual data, follow the market-based factor hierarchy: use the residual mix where available, with grid-average data as the fallback. A mixed-market company therefore still includes those operations in both totals; the two figures for a site may be identical. Missing a preferred certificate does not permit a zero factor or omission of the market-based result.

For example, a group with one office in a market offering contractual instruments and another without them cannot exclude the second office from its market-based total. Document each site's data choice. This describes GHG Protocol reporting; a separate disclosure programme can set its own requirements. Consultation proposals should not be substituted for the published guidance.

Common claims that fail an evidence check

Several shortcuts fail under review. “We bought renewable electricity, therefore our Scope 2 is zero” ignores instrument quality, coverage and uncovered consumption. “The market-based result is the true physical grid impact” confuses contractual allocation with local generation. “Both methods must match” misses the purpose of dual reporting. “Two totals should be added” double-counts the same purchased energy.

Another error is assuming a contract is comparable across all locations. A certificate may have a market boundary and a generation vintage that fit one facility but not another. Equally, a supplier factor may have been calculated before certain attributes were sold. The reader needs the instrument details and calculation hierarchy, not a generic green label.

Finally, do not equate a changing GHG Protocol consultation with a new binding rule. The GHG Protocol reports that its consultation on the 2015 Scope 2 Guidance ran from 20 October 2025 to 31 January 2026. A consultation document is not itself a replacement standard. Use the operative Guidance for current reporting while monitoring formal revisions, and date any policy note so future reviewers know which version was applied.

Build one calculation record for each site

A multi-site workbook needs a stable relationship between consumption and instruments. Give each site's electricity line a period, unit and source record. Store the location-based factor on one route and market-based coverage on another. That prevents a tariff change from quietly overwriting the regional factor used in a different calculation.

For the fictional office, one row identifies 100,000 kWh and its bill. A related instrument record covers 60,000 kWh; the remainder is calculated as 40,000 kWh, not typed independently. If the meter quantity changes, the uncovered remainder must change too. The factor records carry their own units, dates and scope. A simple control rejects negative uncovered consumption rather than using surplus certificates to generate negative electricity emissions.

Derive the remainder rather than typing an unrelated number.
Derive the remainder rather than typing an unrelated number.
Diagram text description

This control detects over-allocation but cannot establish certificate eligibility or banking permission. Surplus instruments do not create negative Scope 2 consumption.

This structure can live in a spreadsheet or a reporting system. Its value is a reproducible relationship, not a product claim. When exporting the result, include the method label and the coverage split so that a recipient can distinguish the two calculations without opening a hidden formula cell.

Use the two results in the right meeting

Bring consumption and operating context to the energy discussion. Bring coverage, instrument eligibility and the uncovered load to procurement. Bring both labelled totals and their calculation basis to reporting. Each audience can then act on the part it controls.

For the office, ten percent less consumption and twenty thousand more covered kilowatt-hours are different proposals. The illustrative calculations show how each affects reporting under fixed factors, but a purchase decision also needs costs, operational feasibility and the company's strategy. Neither figure proves a grid-level climate benefit on its own.

The next useful output is a reconciled site record with an intelligible explanation of the change. Once the meter, coverage and factors are distinct, a reviewer can challenge an assumption without dismantling the entire workbook. That is the practical benefit of understanding location vs market based Scope 2.