Synthetic editorial photograph of a logistics team reviewing a shipment route map at a bright distribution facility; no real company or emissions result is depicted.
Upstream vs Downstream Transportation Scope 3: Category 4 or 9?
Diagram text description

Original synthetic editorial photograph. A synthetic office logistics scene shows a route map, shipment paperwork and two reviewers, with no invented emission data. Spatial grouping, branches, proportions or directional paths carry the claim with concise labels.

A truck leaving your factory is moving outward, but its emissions are not automatically Scope 3 Category 9. If your company buys that third-party delivery service, it belongs in the Category 4 assessment. There is another important case: third-party transport of purchased goods from a direct supplier to your operations falls within Category 4 even when the supplier arranges the delivery. A rule based only on direction or whose name appears on the carrier invoice misses part of the boundary.

Start with the reporting company and a defined freight or storage leg. Establish whether the operation is controlled, where the leg sits relative to purchased or sold goods, and who buys the relevant service. Those facts determine the accounting route. The kilometres and vehicle type matter later for quantification; they cannot decide the category on their own.

The examples below compare the same outward journey under two contracts, trace a supplier-arranged inbound delivery, and split a multi-leg sale into its separate service relationships. They are classification scenarios, not freight-emissions calculations.

Category 4 has two routes into its boundary

The GHG Protocol Category 4 guidance describes both transport of purchased products between a company's tier 1 suppliers and its operations, and third-party transportation or distribution services the company purchases. The purchased-product route excludes fuel and energy products, which have separate treatment. The service route includes purchased outbound logistics and transport between the company's own facilities.

This distinction prevents an omission. Suppose a component supplier includes delivery in its goods price and contracts the independent carrier. The manufacturer's lack of a separate freight invoice does not by itself remove the direct-supplier-to-factory journey from Category 4. The goods, route and operator still need to be identified. Estimating the emissions may be harder without carrier data, but missing data is not the same as an excluded activity.

Category 4 has two distinct entry routes.
Category 4 has two distinct entry routes.
Diagram text description

The left route is third-party transport of purchased goods from the direct supplier to the reporter, including supplier-arranged delivery. The right is transport service bought by the reporter, which can include outbound and interfacility freight. Controlled operations and fuel/energy exceptions are assessed separately.

For an outward delivery, the service purchaser becomes decisive in distinguishing purchased outbound freight from non-purchased downstream transport. A customer-arranged post-sale leg can be a Category 9 candidate for the seller, while the seller's own purchased delivery is assessed in Category 4. These are separate applications of the boundary, not contradictory descriptions of the road.

Before either test, check controlled operations. Transport inside the company's organisational boundary is first a Scope 1 or Scope 2 question as appropriate. Some leased or other arrangements may lead to another Scope 3 category. The comparison here must not force every possible transport activity into only 4 or 9.

Hold the road constant and change the service arrangement

Imagine the same finished goods moving from a manufacturer's factory to a customer's warehouse along the same road. In the first arrangement, the manufacturer contracts an independent carrier for delivery. In the second, the customer buys the goods and independently contracts the onward transport. The route, load and distance can be identical while the manufacturer's category assessment changes.

The first is purchased outbound transport, assessed in Category 4. The second is third-party post-sale movement not purchased by the manufacturer, assessed in Category 9. A route arrow therefore cannot carry the classification by itself. The arrow shows physical movement; a separate relationship identifies the reporting entity and service purchase.

This thought experiment is deliberately limited to an outbound sold-product leg. It should not be reversed into a rule that every supplier-arranged inbound delivery falls outside Category 4. That leg has the purchased-product route described above. Read the relevant boundary before applying a shortcut learned from one example.

Incoterms and delivery clauses help establish the facts, but a familiar abbreviation should not replace the actual agreement. A forwarder, purchasing agent or marketplace may act for another party. Identify the economic service arrangement and the part of the journey it covers, rather than assigning the entire order from one invoice heading.

When purchased outbound freight is Category 4

Suppose your company contracts an independent carrier to bring purchased components to your production site. That is an obvious candidate for Category 4. Supplier-arranged delivery of those purchased components from the direct supplier is also within the purchased-product boundary; a separately bought freight service is not the only route into this category. Now suppose you contract the same carrier to deliver finished products to a customer. The truck is travelling outward, but your company is still purchasing the freight service. The GHG Protocol's Category 4 guidance identifies purchased outbound logistics as upstream transportation and distribution for the reporter. This is not a special exception invented to increase an inventory; it follows the purchased-service boundary.

Do not stop at “seller paid” if the contract is complex. A marketplace, freight forwarder or distributor may contract the service; a bundled goods price may obscure which party actually purchased a particular leg. There may be a separate inbound leg, warehouse stay and final-mile delivery with different purchasers. Identify the reporting entity, service purchaser, operator and boundaries for each segment. If evidence is incomplete, label the classification provisional and ask a specific question rather than assigning the whole route by intuition.

Outward travel can still be a purchased Category 4 service.
Outward travel can still be a purchased Category 4 service.
Diagram text description

The arrows show physical outbound movement. In this example the reporter purchases the third-party freight. Direction alone does not select Category 9; the section states the service-purchase relationship.

Once Category 4 is confirmed, calculate using a method and activity data appropriate to that category. The GHG Protocol's technical guidance discusses fuel-based, distance-based and spend-based approaches, each with different input quality. That methodological choice comes after classification; a precise tonne-kilometre calculation does not repair a wrong category.

When sold-product delivery is Category 9

Category 9 is not a catch-all for anything that happens after a product leaves the site. The GHG Protocol describes downstream transportation and distribution of sold products in third-party vehicles and facilities, including relevant storage and retail, when that service is not purchased by the reporting company. The report's sale and control boundaries determine where the downstream chain begins. The same document expressly excludes purchased outbound services from Category 9 and puts them in Category 4.

Imagine a customer purchases finished goods and independently arranges the next delivery with a carrier. Subject to the actual transfer and service facts, that subsequent third-party movement is a Category 9 candidate for the seller. If the seller instead contracts and pays the carrier for that movement, it may be Category 4 for the seller even though the goods are headed to the customer. If the customer uses its own fleet, the buyer's inventory perspective is different from the seller's; do not copy one entity's category label into another's records.

This post-sale movement is not bought by the reporter.
This post-sale movement is not bought by the reporter.
Diagram text description

The sequence shows the explicitly assumed Category 9 case: third-party distribution of sold products after the point of sale, not purchased by the reporter. It is not a rule that all customer-arranged inbound transport belongs in Category 9.

Retail and distribution facilities require the same care. Identify who operates them, whether they sit within the reporter's controlled operations, and whether their services were bought by the reporter. A chain of storage and delivery should be segmented where ownership, service purchaser or sale status changes. The category follows the segment, not the marketing label “last mile”.

First exclude the company’s own vehicles and facilities

Before choosing either Scope 3 freight category, test whether the transport operation is inside the reporting company's organizational boundary. Fuel burned by a vehicle the company owns or controls is normally a direct-emissions question. Purchased electricity for a controlled electric fleet or facility is normally considered under Scope 2, subject to the company's consolidation approach. The operation is not made “downstream Scope 3” merely because the vehicle drives to a customer.

This branch matters when contracts involve leased vehicles, franchise operators, outsourced warehouses or jointly managed facilities. A vehicle can bear your brand while another entity operates it. A carrier can be a separate legal business even if it serves only your route. Conversely, a truck may have a third-party owner but fall under an operational-control boundary depending on the arrangement. Do not infer control from livery or ownership shorthand. Apply the company's documented consolidation method to the actual operation.

Assess controlled vehicle operations before third-party freight.
Assess controlled vehicle operations before third-party freight.
Diagram text description

The enclosing boundary denotes the reporter’s control under its chosen organisational approach. Fuel combustion and purchased electricity are assessed through Scope 1 and Scope 2 respectively. Leasing classification requires its own control assessment.

Keep the evidence that supports the boundary: operating agreement, asset register, fleet fuel records, electricity bills, carrier contract and organizational-control decision. If the controlled-operation test resolves the leg, there is no need to force it into Category 4 or Category 9 as well. If it does not, continue to the third-party service-purchaser and sale tests.

Use a sequence that keeps the inbound case visible

First define the reporter and leg, then test the organisational boundary. A controlled truck or facility goes to the relevant direct or purchased-energy accounting before considering third-party Scope 3 freight. Where a lease falls outside that boundary, check the applicable leased-asset guidance rather than assuming Category 9.

For third-party transport, ask whether this is the movement of purchased products from a direct supplier to the reporter's operations. If so, assess Category 4 under that boundary, with the fuel-and-energy exception considered separately. If it is transport farther upstream between the supplier's suppliers, it may already be within the purchased product's Category 1 cradle-to-gate data.

Then consider other purchased transportation and distribution services, including outbound and inter-facility services. Those also enter the Category 4 assessment. For sold-product movement after sale that the reporter did not purchase, assess Category 9. If none of these descriptions fits, leave the category unresolved until the appropriate definition is established.

This sequence distinguishes two questions that can otherwise collapse into one: where the purchased product travels, and who purchases another transport service. It also makes the limits visible. Classification is not established by the word inbound, by a payment code alone or by a branch that sends every No answer to Category 9.

Split a sale into legs with different reporting relationships

Consider a manufacturer buying components and selling finished goods. The component supplier arranges delivery to the factory. The manufacturer later buys transport from the factory to a port. After the sale point, the customer independently buys the ocean and final delivery legs. Assume all carriers are independent and the relevant operations are outside the manufacturer's control.

From the manufacturer's perspective, the direct-supplier delivery is assessed in Category 4 under the purchased-product boundary. The factory-to-port service is also Category 4 because the manufacturer purchases it. The customer-arranged post-sale legs are Category 9 candidates. One commercial sale therefore creates more than one classification record.

One shipment can cross separately classified legs.
One shipment can cross separately classified legs.
Diagram text description

The first leg is supplier-arranged purchased-goods delivery; the next is outbound freight bought by the reporter; the last is assumed post-sale transport bought by the customer. Labels name the classifications for these stated circumstances. The separate own-fleet case in the table remains Scope 1/2.

Table 1: scroll horizontally if needed.

Leg Relevant facts in this scenario Manufacturer's assessment
Direct supplier to factory Purchased components; independent carrier arranged by supplier Category 4 purchased-product transport
Factory to port Manufacturer purchases independent freight Category 4 purchased service
Post-sale ocean and onward delivery Customer purchases independent transport Category 9
Manufacturer-controlled local delivery, if used instead Controlled vehicle replaces that service leg Scope 1 or 2 as applicable

Change the agreement and revisit only the affected legs. If the manufacturer starts purchasing the ocean service, that service moves to the Category 4 assessment even if the route is unchanged. If the customer takes responsibility only at a later distribution hub, the post-sale and service boundaries must be established for the revised chain. A single Category 4 or 9 label attached to the order would hide those changes.

The example does not provide quantities or emissions factors. Its purpose is to produce a leg map that a subsequent calculation can use without counting the same service twice or omitting supplier-arranged inbound transport.

What records make the decision auditable

A defensible category decision has a small evidence bundle. Link the shipment or route identifier to the carrier or facility operator, transport contract, service invoice or charge, goods sale and hand-off records, warehouse arrangement and the reporting company's control assessment. Include the reporting period, entity and any assumptions about an agent or subcontractor. If an Incoterm is used, store it with the transaction, but do not treat it as a substitute for reading who actually purchased each service.

Record the decision itself in a stable field: Category 4, Category 9, Scope 1/2 controlled operation, other category, or unresolved. Beside it record the rule applied and the document that proves each decisive fact. A reviewer should be able to ask “why is an outward shipment upstream?” and receive a concise answer: because the reporting company bought this independently operated outbound freight leg, as shown by the named agreement and invoice. A long model output without that answer is weak evidence.

Make corrections traceable. A disputed invoice, altered delivery term or late carrier record may change the category for a leg. Preserve the previous classification, reviewer, date and reason; avoid silently replacing a value that was used in a prior report. The same discipline makes later calculation and internal audit faster because the category does not have to be reconstructed from memory.

Choose activity data after settling the category

Classification and quantification require different evidence. Contracts, control and purchase or sale relationships establish the accounting route. Fuel, mass, distance, mode, storage energy and allocation assumptions establish the quantity. A detailed carrier emissions statement cannot decide who bought a service; a correct category label cannot make an incomplete carrier statement representative of the shipment.

The GHG Protocol technical guidance offers fuel-, distance- and spend-based approaches where applicable. Choose the route supported by the available data and the relevant category instructions. In a distance-based example, shipment mass and distance need a compatible intensity denominator and transport boundary. Do not mix an actual route distance with an intensity whose allocation or distance convention makes that combination inconsistent.

Category and quantity answer different questions.
Category and quantity answer different questions.
Diagram text description

The left path establishes the reporting relationship. The right establishes a numerical estimate using a compatible method and factor boundary. A category label supplies neither a distance nor an intensity; the two outputs must be reconciled for the same leg.

Storage needs its own activity and allocation treatment where included. A tonne-kilometre line for the road leg does not automatically include a distribution centre's electricity. Conversely, a carrier's combined service estimate may already contain handling or storage. Identify what the supplied result includes before adding another line.

The practical output of classification is a defined set of activities to quantify. Keep the uncertain inputs visible and seek the data that changes the estimate, instead of using numerical precision to conceal an unresolved route or service boundary.

A final check for double counting and category changes

At the end of a reporting period, test a sample of apparently unusual legs: outbound freight recorded as Category 4, inbound freight booked under a customer arrangement, third-party storage after sale, and deliveries involving an own fleet or a subcontractor. Reconcile the leg list to carrier invoices and shipment records. A missing leg, a duplicate service charge or a route grouped across two contracts can create more error than a small factor difference.

Check mutual exclusivity from the reporting company's viewpoint. The same third-party leg should not be counted once as purchased Category 4 freight and again as non-purchased Category 9 distribution. When a contract changes midyear, do not assume the old classification carries forward. Version the decision and, if material, revisit affected estimates. A useful review note states the rule, source documents, period and any unresolved exception.

The practical answer is not that every shipment has one category forever. It is that each reporting entity can make an explainable, evidence-backed choice for each distinct service leg. Physical direction is a useful description of the route; the GHG Protocol classification rests on the transaction and control facts behind it.

Close the missing-leg problem, not just the invoice list

The difficult case is often the journey for which the reporter has no separate transport invoice. A delivered-goods price may conceal direct-supplier freight; a customer may arrange onward transport after sale; a forwarder may combine several legs in one charge. An invoice-only inventory can omit activities even when every visible charge has a category.

Reconcile the physical shipment chain to the classified leg list. For the worked sale, confirm that inbound components, factory-to-port freight and the known post-sale chain each have a destination in the assessment. Where the final use of an intermediate product is unknown, follow the applicable Category 9 boundary rather than inventing an end-consumer route.

The final decision should explain the particular leg. “Category 4 because it is direct-supplier transport of purchased components” is different from “Category 4 because we bought the outbound service.” That distinction makes the classification resilient when a contract changes, and prevents a useful rule about one journey from becoming a misleading rule for every journey.