An unbranded cargo aircraft on an airport apron at dawn beside wrapped cargo pallets and containers.
Connect the shipment estimate with the cargo movement it describes.
Diagram text description

The original synthetic editorial scene shows an unbranded cargo aircraft at dawn beside wrapped pallets and containers, with an open loading area. It provides airport-operation context only; it does not identify the fictional AF-204 shipment, verify a carrier or establish measured emissions.

Air freight carbon emissions for a shipment are usually an allocated estimate of the flight activity associated with moving that cargo. The number depends on the shipment, route, aircraft service, allocation method and emissions boundary. It is not a sensor reading taken from the package.

Start by identifying the shipment and setting the boundary. Collect its activity records, choose a suitable calculation method, allocate the relevant emissions, then review the result and update it when better evidence arrives. Keep what is known separate from what the method models: a declared origin and destination do not establish the actual routing or fuel burned.

The practical aim is a reconstructable result that helps a shipping decision. This guide explains the evidence choices and works through a fictional two-leg shipment. Its arithmetic demonstrates compatible units and acceptance checks; the invented coefficient is neither an official default nor a measured carrier factor. A result can be useful for learning while remaining unsuitable for an operational or public claim.

First define the shipment and emissions boundary

Define the movement and the result before collecting factors. Is the question about an airport-to-airport flight, or the complete service from collection to delivery? Does the result describe CO2 from fuel combustion, tank-to-wheel CO2e, or well-to-wheel CO2e including upstream fuel production? These choices affect what may be added and compared.

A flight-only CO2 result and a wider door-to-door CO2e result cover different activities and potentially different gases. A wider service may include collection trucks, flights, storage and delivery. However, CO2e does not automatically mean door to door, and a door-to-door result does not by itself establish a lifecycle fuel boundary. State the logistics coverage and the gas/fuel basis separately.

Flight-only CO2 covers the air movement. A wider service CO2e result may include road, air and storage with a stated lifecycle basis.
Check both the activities included and the gases reported.
Diagram text description

The left group represents a flight-only CO2 result for the air movement. The right group represents an explicitly wider service CO2e result that includes road, air and storage under its selected lifecycle method. These are examples of different choices, not definitions that every CO2e result is door to door. Align gases, fuel boundary and logistics coverage before comparing totals.

ICAO’s Air Freighter methodology, Version 2 dated July 2024, describes a predictive flight CO2 estimate for dedicated freighters. It does not calculate the shipment’s other transport modes. Its modelled answer should not be renamed a measured flight result or a complete logistics CO2e footprint.

Write the boundary beside the number, including the origin and destination, included legs and excluded activities. Where non-CO2 aviation effects are relevant to the decision, identify whether the chosen method addresses them. Do not assume a generic uplift is included or append one without a documented basis. Matching unit symbols alone is insufficient when the underlying coverage differs.

Collect the activity data that changes the answer

Build the activity record around one shipment ID and distinct leg IDs. Keep the original documents and distinguish actual operational evidence from planned routing or modelling assumptions. A forwarder’s invoice and an air waybill can describe the same movement; two documents do not necessarily represent two activities.

Data fieldEvidence to requestGap or compatibility check
Shipment and massShipment ID, packing or weight record, shipped kilograms and dateDistinguish physical shipped mass from chargeable weight; use the basis required by the method
Route and legsOrigin, hub, destination, flight or routing records where knownMark planned, modelled and actual distance bases separately
Aircraft serviceDedicated freighter or passenger belly cargo; aircraft type where availableHold a service-specific coefficient if the service is unknown
Operator and timingCarrier, service date, operational evidence and document identityConfirm that the data apply to this shipment and period
Other logisticsCollection, delivery and warehouse activity if includedRetain separate records; missing data do not mean zero emissions

Table 1, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Data field
Shipment and mass
Evidence to request
Shipment ID, packing or weight record, shipped kilograms and date
Gap or compatibility check
Distinguish physical shipped mass from chargeable weight; use the basis required by the method

Row 2

Data field
Route and legs
Evidence to request
Origin, hub, destination, flight or routing records where known
Gap or compatibility check
Mark planned, modelled and actual distance bases separately

Row 3

Data field
Aircraft service
Evidence to request
Dedicated freighter or passenger belly cargo; aircraft type where available
Gap or compatibility check
Hold a service-specific coefficient if the service is unknown

Row 4

Data field
Operator and timing
Evidence to request
Carrier, service date, operational evidence and document identity
Gap or compatibility check
Confirm that the data apply to this shipment and period

Row 5

Data field
Other logistics
Evidence to request
Collection, delivery and warehouse activity if included
Gap or compatibility check
Retain separate records; missing data do not mean zero emissions

A handling unit can include packaging, pallets or containers whose treatment depends on the method. Record the mass definition rather than changing it silently to match a convenient coefficient. Preserve units when converting a carrier file into an internal table.

For a transfer shipment, record each actual or assumed air leg instead of substituting the direct origin-to-destination distance without explanation. If the carrier later supplies a different route, retain the original estimate and identify what changed. This makes a revised result explainable rather than merely different.

Choose the most defensible calculation route

Choose the calculation route that best matches the available evidence and intended use. Suitable carrier fuel and operational data can support a more specific allocation than a generic estimate. They still need a defined boundary, method and shipment relationship; a carrier logo is not sufficient evidence of those choices.

RouteWhat supports the calculationMain limitation
Carrier operational evidenceApplicable fuel, flight activity, cargo loads and documented allocationConfirm coverage and allocation; company-wide averages are not automatically shipment-specific
Route or aircraft modelShipment mass, route assumptions, aircraft/service information and model versionPredictive routing, fleet and load assumptions may differ from actual operation
Mass-distance estimateTonnes shipped, leg kilometres and a compatible emissions factorFactor service, geography, period and boundary must match the activity
Spend screeningFreight expenditure and a documented monetary factorPrice changes and service mix limit physical interpretation; label it screening

Table 2, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Route
Carrier operational evidence
What supports the calculation
Applicable fuel, flight activity, cargo loads and documented allocation
Main limitation
Confirm coverage and allocation; company-wide averages are not automatically shipment-specific

Row 2

Route
Route or aircraft model
What supports the calculation
Shipment mass, route assumptions, aircraft/service information and model version
Main limitation
Predictive routing, fleet and load assumptions may differ from actual operation

Row 3

Route
Mass-distance estimate
What supports the calculation
Tonnes shipped, leg kilometres and a compatible emissions factor
Main limitation
Factor service, geography, period and boundary must match the activity

Row 4

Route
Spend screening
What supports the calculation
Freight expenditure and a documented monetary factor
Main limitation
Price changes and service mix limit physical interpretation; label it screening

IATA’s cargo-emissions publisher page identifies Recommended Practice 1678 as a shipment-level methodology and describes updates adopted in 2022. That publisher description establishes the method’s identity; it is not a factor table or evidence that a particular carrier followed it for your shipment.

ICAO’s reviewed freighter edition uses model inputs, including routing, aircraft and load information, to predict emissions. The simple mass-distance exercise below is a separate teaching calculation, not a reproduction of that calculator. Keep the method version and the actual data source together so a reader can distinguish an operational estimate, a modelled estimate and a spend-based screen.

Freighter and passenger belly cargo are not the same

A dedicated freighter and passenger belly cargo allocate flight activity over different transported loads. A freighter carries cargo, while a passenger flight carries passengers, baggage and cargo under an applicable allocation rule. The same endpoints and distance cannot make those relationships interchangeable.

Belly cargo is not automatically assigned zero because the passenger flight was scheduled anyway. Equally, a dedicated-freighter coefficient should not be transferred to belly cargo without evidence that its method applies. Request the aircraft service and allocation basis rather than inferring them from an airline name.

A dedicated freighter allocates flight activity to cargo. A passenger flight needs a rule for passengers, baggage and belly cargo.
Match the aircraft service and allocation method to the cargo.
Diagram text description

The freighter side contains cargo and its load allocation. The passenger-flight side contains passengers, baggage and cargo sharing flight activity under a different rule. Belly cargo is not assigned zero simply because the passenger flight exists, and the same distance does not justify reusing a freighter factor. Check the applicable service and allocation before accepting a shipment result.

Check the coefficient denominator. It may represent cargo tonne-kilometres after allocation, emissions per kilogram carried, or another defined output. If allocation is already embedded in the factor, adding a second arbitrary cargo share can distort the result. If you start from flight fuel instead, you need the method’s load and allocation evidence.

The fictional calculation uses a coefficient defined only for its invented dedicated-freighter service. No belly-cargo estimate follows from it. When the actual service is unknown, hold acceptance of that service-specific result until the evidence resolves the mismatch.

Work through a transparent shipment example

Explicitly fictional teaching example: shipment AF-204 carries 200 kg on two invented dedicated-freighter legs during May 2025. Physical mass is 0.2 tonnes. Distances are assumed air-leg distances, not verified flight tracks. Coefficient T-1 is invented as 0.75 kg CO2 per tonne-kilometre, already allocated to cargo, covering combustion CO2 only. It is not an IATA, ICAO or measured carrier factor.

Leg identityAssumed air distanceMass-distance activityFictional calculationResult
AF-204-L1: North Quay to Mesa Hub2,400 km0.2 t × 2,400 km = 480 t·km480 × 0.75 kg CO2/(t·km)360 kg CO2
AF-204-L2: Mesa Hub to Lake Gate1,600 km0.2 t × 1,600 km = 320 t·km320 × 0.75 kg CO2/(t·km)240 kg CO2
AF-204: both unique air legs4,000 km total480 + 320 = 800 t·km800 × 0.75 kg CO2/(t·km)600 kg CO2
Factor acceptance controlDistances still assumed800 t·kmReal estimate is 800F until a sourced, route-appropriate F is justifiedNo real-shipment result established

Table 3, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Leg identity
AF-204-L1: North Quay to Mesa Hub
Assumed air distance
2,400 km
Mass-distance activity
0.2 t × 2,400 km = 480 t·km
Fictional calculation
480 × 0.75 kg CO2/(t·km)
Result
360 kg CO2

Row 2

Leg identity
AF-204-L2: Mesa Hub to Lake Gate
Assumed air distance
1,600 km
Mass-distance activity
0.2 t × 1,600 km = 320 t·km
Fictional calculation
320 × 0.75 kg CO2/(t·km)
Result
240 kg CO2

Row 3

Leg identity
AF-204: both unique air legs
Assumed air distance
4,000 km total
Mass-distance activity
480 + 320 = 800 t·km
Fictional calculation
800 × 0.75 kg CO2/(t·km)
Result
600 kg CO2

Row 4

Leg identity
Factor acceptance control
Assumed air distance
Distances still assumed
Mass-distance activity
800 t·km
Fictional calculation
Real estimate is 800F until a sourced, route-appropriate F is justified
Result
No real-shipment result established

The symbolic structure is 200 kg ÷ 1,000 = 0.2 t; multiplied by 4,000 km, this gives 800 tonne-kilometres. For a real shipment the result would be 800F, where F must be a justified, route-appropriate factor with matching units and scope. The 600 kg CO2 teaching answer exists only because this exercise defines an invented coefficient. It is not a defensible real-shipment result.

Apply two acceptance controls. First, an invoice and waybill both referring to AF-204-L1 must link to the same leg. Adding its 360 kg again would create a false 960 kg total. Second, entering 200 as tonnes instead of converting kilograms would produce 600,000 kg CO2, a thousandfold error; reject that unit mismatch.

For a separate fictional sensitivity, change only T-1 to 0.90 kg CO2/(t·km), with activity and boundary fixed. The answer becomes 720 kg CO2, 20% higher. No road legs, warehousing, upstream fuel emissions, other greenhouse gases or non-CO2 aviation effects are included. The coefficient does not apply to belly cargo. Replace the assumptions with compatible carrier evidence before relying on the estimate.

Compare transport choices on a like-for-like basis

Compare actual transport proposals after aligning the cargo and service being assessed. A lower-looking number may describe a shorter boundary, a different gas basis or an option that cannot meet the delivery requirement. Universal air-to-sea or air-to-rail multipliers conceal these differences.

Comparison testEvidence needed before deciding
Same cargo and destinationEquivalent quantity, handling needs and final delivery point
Complete routeCollection, transfers, main transport, storage and delivery included consistently
Same emissions basisMatching gases, fuel lifecycle scope and reported unit
Comparable factor evidenceApplicable geography, service, period, load and allocation basis
Service feasibilityDelivery time, reliability, storage needs and product condition
Unknown fieldResolve the gap or hold the comparison; an unknown boundary is not a pass

Table 4, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Comparison test
Same cargo and destination
Evidence needed before deciding
Equivalent quantity, handling needs and final delivery point

Row 2

Comparison test
Complete route
Evidence needed before deciding
Collection, transfers, main transport, storage and delivery included consistently

Row 3

Comparison test
Same emissions basis
Evidence needed before deciding
Matching gases, fuel lifecycle scope and reported unit

Row 4

Comparison test
Comparable factor evidence
Evidence needed before deciding
Applicable geography, service, period, load and allocation basis

Row 5

Comparison test
Service feasibility
Evidence needed before deciding
Delivery time, reliability, storage needs and product condition

Row 6

Comparison test
Unknown field
Evidence needed before deciding
Resolve the gap or hold the comparison; an unknown boundary is not a pass

Ask whether an alternative changes more than the main transport mode. A slower route may need additional storage, or the proposed service may still contain an air leg. Retain those activities instead of comparing an airport-to-airport air result with an incomplete port-to-port alternative.

If the evidence is incomplete, present the unresolved difference and the next request. Do not calculate a percentage saving from incompatible totals. The fictional AF-204 combustion-only result cannot establish a lifecycle CO2e saving against a sea or rail quotation. A useful comparison explains both the estimated emissions and whether the proposed service can actually deliver the same goods under the required conditions.

Turn a calculation into a repeatable shipment record

Filled fictional reconstruction record: this record describes AF-204 only. Every shipment detail, distance and coefficient is invented. It shows how a reviewer could reconstruct the teaching answer and identify the evidence still needed for real acceptance.

Record fieldFilled fictional value
Shipment and periodAF-204; May 2025; invented North Quay–Mesa Hub–Lake Gate routing
Unique legs and documentsAF-204-L1 and AF-204-L2; invoice and waybill references for L1 link to one leg
Declared mass200 kg physical shipped mass = 0.2 t on each leg; no chargeable-weight substitution
Distance basisAssumed 2,400 km and 1,600 km air-leg distances; 4,000 km combined; no verified flight tracks
Mode and allocationInvented dedicated freighter; cargo allocation embedded in T-1; no extra allocation multiplier
Method and coefficientMass-distance teaching method; T-1 version 1; invented 0.75 kg CO2/(t·km); not an official published factor
Calculation and result480 t·km gives 360 kg CO2; 320 t·km gives 240 kg CO2; unique-leg total 600 kg CO2
Emissions boundaryAir-leg fuel-combustion CO2 only; not lifecycle CO2e
ExclusionsCollection/delivery road legs, storage, upstream fuel, other gases and non-CO2 aviation effects
Evidence and reviewerTeaching status only; illustrative reviewer Shipping Analyst; carrier/service, mass, route and applicable factor evidence unresolved
Acceptance and update triggerHold operational acceptance; revise when carrier evidence confirms routing, allocation, service and emissions basis

Table 5, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Record field
Shipment and period
Filled fictional value
AF-204; May 2025; invented North Quay–Mesa Hub–Lake Gate routing

Row 2

Record field
Unique legs and documents
Filled fictional value
AF-204-L1 and AF-204-L2; invoice and waybill references for L1 link to one leg

Row 3

Record field
Declared mass
Filled fictional value
200 kg physical shipped mass = 0.2 t on each leg; no chargeable-weight substitution

Row 4

Record field
Distance basis
Filled fictional value
Assumed 2,400 km and 1,600 km air-leg distances; 4,000 km combined; no verified flight tracks

Row 5

Record field
Mode and allocation
Filled fictional value
Invented dedicated freighter; cargo allocation embedded in T-1; no extra allocation multiplier

Row 6

Record field
Method and coefficient
Filled fictional value
Mass-distance teaching method; T-1 version 1; invented 0.75 kg CO2/(t·km); not an official published factor

Row 7

Record field
Calculation and result
Filled fictional value
480 t·km gives 360 kg CO2; 320 t·km gives 240 kg CO2; unique-leg total 600 kg CO2

Row 8

Record field
Emissions boundary
Filled fictional value
Air-leg fuel-combustion CO2 only; not lifecycle CO2e

Row 9

Record field
Exclusions
Filled fictional value
Collection/delivery road legs, storage, upstream fuel, other gases and non-CO2 aviation effects

Row 10

Record field
Evidence and reviewer
Filled fictional value
Teaching status only; illustrative reviewer Shipping Analyst; carrier/service, mass, route and applicable factor evidence unresolved

Row 11

Record field
Acceptance and update trigger
Filled fictional value
Hold operational acceptance; revise when carrier evidence confirms routing, allocation, service and emissions basis

Keep the source documents attached to the relevant leg identities, alongside the coefficient version and calculation. An updated invoice should not create a new physical leg unless it documents another movement.

When evidence arrives, record whether the change concerns activity, method, allocation or boundary. Retain the previous result and explain any difference. A reviewer can then distinguish a corrected mass from a new route or a wider lifecycle method. The filled table supports reconstruction; it does not turn fictional inputs into measured data or provide independent assurance.

Where this fits in an organization’s inventory

The calculation describes a movement; inventory classification describes its relationship to a particular reporting company. Keep those decisions separate. The same third-party shipment can be relevant to different value chains without one shipment total automatically identifying the correct reporting category.

Check whether the company owns or controls the transport asset, or purchases a third-party transport service. Retain the company boundary, contract and payment evidence. Purchased third-party freight may be relevant to upstream transportation and distribution, but the company’s actual relationship and the applicable inventory rules need review.

One shipment result leads to separate checks for owned or controlled transport and purchased third-party service before inventory classification.
Calculate the movement, then check the company’s reporting relationship.
Diagram text description

Retain the calculated shipment result. For inventory mapping, examine whether the transport asset is owned or controlled by the reporting company or whether the movement is a purchased third-party service. Those relationships guide the subsequent reporting treatment. The diagram does not assign every air movement to Category 4; the company boundary, contract and payment evidence still need review.

Do not classify every air shipment as Scope 3 Category 4 merely because it is freight. Owned or controlled transport follows a different assessment, and the responsibility for purchasing the service can matter. The dedicated Category 4 explanation addresses that mapping in more detail; this article stays focused on reconstructing the movement calculation. Preserve the shipment result and its boundary so the inventory reviewer can use it without recreating the arithmetic.

What to do after the baseline

Use the baseline as a starting point for better evidence and a practical service decision. Segment recurring lanes by cargo needs, route, service urgency and method quality. Ask the carrier for applicable operational data, then test a feasible alternative where timing and handling permit.

Observe the service outcome as well as the emissions estimate. Record delivery time, condition, reliability and additional logistics activity. Feed those findings into the next procurement decision instead of assuming that a different transport label guarantees a saving.

Separate physical change from a calculation change. A lower revised estimate might reflect a better load assumption or a different factor rather than a change in the shipment. Keep a consistent comparison basis, and explain why the number moved. This is particularly important when replacing a broad baseline with more specific carrier evidence.

For AF-204, the immediate task would be to replace invented distances, service details and T-1 with compatible evidence, resolve the excluded activities needed by the intended boundary, and review the result. No generic percentage reduction follows from the exercise. The useful next action is the evidence request or service test that can change an actual shipping decision.

Maintain shipment evidence for review

Maintain the shipment evidence in a form that another person can follow: product or order identity, leg IDs, original mass and route records, coefficient version, calculation, exclusions and reviewer disposition. Structured product and supplier records can provide context, but they do not establish the emissions of a particular flight.

Before choosing support, check what the proposed system or service actually does. Ask whether it retains the applicable method, exposes allocation assumptions, links duplicate documents to one movement and preserves unresolved evidence. Confirm any carrier-data connection or assurance scope separately rather than inferring it from a carbon-related product description.

An organized record helps a reviewer reproduce the result and request missing information. Keep the operational estimate, inventory classification and permission to communicate a claim as distinct decisions. For the next shipment, start with its identity and boundary, use the best compatible evidence available, and retain the limits alongside the number.