A person holds a pen over an open notebook beside binders, a laptop and a small sample vial.
A credit review brings together project records, monitoring evidence and the exact unit records.
Diagram text description

A person sits at a desk with an open notebook, laptop and binders. A glass vial and a tray contain dark loose material. No project identifiers or measurements are visible.

Verified carbon credits are units associated with reductions or removals that have undergone an independent assessment under a crediting programme. Check what the assessor actually covered and whether the programme issued the units being offered. In Verra’s Verified Carbon Standard programme, for example, each Verified Carbon Unit represents one tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent, or CO₂e, under the programme’s rules.

A buyer needs four separate checks. Unit identity answers which serials and status the registry records. Project quality concerns the activity, baseline and measurement method. Safeguards concern effects on people and ecosystems. Claim fit asks whether the planned use and wording are supported by the buyer’s records and the applicable rules. A strong result on any one check leaves the other three to resolve.

Treat unit identity, project quality, safeguards and claim fit as separate tests.
Treat unit identity, project quality, safeguards and claim fit as separate tests.
Diagram text description

Match exact units and status. Review the quality of the underlying project and credited outcome. Review affected people and ecosystems. Test whether the credit and records suit the stated use or wording. Each check has its own evidence.

Start with the project and batch references. Then use the evidence comparison below to decide where to continue, request records or stop. Before making a retirement-based statement, reconcile the transaction and beneficiary to the exact units covered by the words.

Trace the unit through the programme and registry

Ask the seller for the programme, project number, methodology and version, monitoring period, vintage and serial or batch references. The vintage is the period the unit relates to under the programme’s definition. Use these details to find the project and its records through the programme, and compare them with the offer.

EvidenceWhat to match
Validation reportThe project design and methodology assessed, including the version and any conditions
Verification reportThe monitored activity, quantified outcome, covered period and issues raised by the assessor
Registry issuance entryThe project, vintage, quantity and identifiers of the issued batch
Registry transaction evidenceThe holder or authorised account, the exact units and their current status

Table 1, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Evidence
Validation report
What to match
The project design and methodology assessed, including the version and any conditions

Row 2

Evidence
Verification report
What to match
The monitored activity, quantified outcome, covered period and issues raised by the assessor

Row 3

Evidence
Registry issuance entry
What to match
The project, vintage, quantity and identifiers of the issued batch

Row 4

Evidence
Registry transaction evidence
What to match
The holder or authorised account, the exact units and their current status

Follow the links between those records. A verification report may cover a different monitoring period from the units in the offer. If the batch was split, ask for the precise ranges the seller can deliver and compare them with the original issuance. A private account may require an extract from the authorised holder. Record who supplied it and which public facts can be matched independently.

If the period or identifiers conflict, ask the seller to reconcile them before approving the purchase. Keep a copy of the offer and the batch evidence so the person checking delivery can repeat the match.

Test additionality and the baseline

Additionality asks whether the activity, or the outcome being credited, would have occurred without the incentive from crediting. The baseline estimates emissions or removals under the relevant alternative scenario. A reviewer needs evidence for both, because a project can describe an ambitious intervention while using a baseline that inflates its effect.

Review questionEvidence to test
Would the activity go ahead anyway?Legal obligations, investment or adoption records, barriers and common practice under the applicable methodology
What would happen in its absence?Assumptions, data and comparable activity used to build the baseline, with the geography and time period they represent
How sensitive is the result?The effect of changing a consequential baseline assumption and how the method handles uncertainty

Table 2, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Review question
Would the activity go ahead anyway?
Evidence to test
Legal obligations, investment or adoption records, barriers and common practice under the applicable methodology

Row 2

Review question
What would happen in its absence?
Evidence to test
Assumptions, data and comparable activity used to build the baseline, with the geography and time period they represent

Row 3

Review question
How sensitive is the result?
Evidence to test
The effect of changing a consequential baseline assumption and how the method handles uncertainty

Consider an industrial capture project that cites routine venting at older facilities. Ask whether the host site already had to capture the same gas during the crediting period, and whether those facilities faced comparable rules and operating conditions. Compare the permit and investment record with the dates used in the project assessment. Ask the assessor or programme how the method treats obligations introduced during the crediting period.

A baseline with greater assumed emissions can make the credited improvement look larger. Ask which assumptions drive the quantity, what evidence supports them and whether the method applies a conservative treatment where evidence is weak. Give unresolved assumptions to a reviewer with access to the method and the underlying records.

Assess measurement, leakage and permanence

Follow the credited quantity from the monitoring report to the issuance entry. Identify which values were measured, which were estimated and how the project treated gaps. Where a gas meter supplies a key input, ask for calibration records, the procedure for outages and the period each record covers. Compare the verification conclusion with any corrective actions or exclusions. A report can verify one period while leaving another period outside its scope.

Next ask whether the activity could shift emissions elsewhere. This is leakage. For example, restricting harvest in one area could shift some activity beyond the project boundary. Look for the sources of leakage the method considers, the evidence used to estimate them and the effect on the credited quantity. Where an exclusion drives the result, ask the reviewer to record its basis.

For stored carbon, ask how a reversal would be detected, reported and addressed. A reversal occurs when some of the stored carbon is released. Where a programme uses a shared reserve of units, review what that reserve covers and who is responsible for monitoring and responding to a loss. The appropriate questions depend on the storage mechanism and methodology.

Tie every material adjustment to the same monitoring period as the batch. If you cannot reconcile the monitored outcome, applied adjustments and issued quantity, hold the quantity review open.

Reconcile the monitored outcome to the baseline and the issued batch for the same period.
Reconcile the monitored outcome to the baseline and the issued batch for the same period.
Diagram text description

Test whether the proposed activity was already required or routine and whether the baseline represents the credible alternative. Check which monitored inputs were measured or estimated. Trace leakage adjustments and applicable reversal controls and match the period and issued quantity.

Review environmental and social safeguards

Carbon evidence tells a buyer little about who bore the cost of the activity. Review the safeguards for the actual project and the people and places it affects. Start by identifying the rights holders, workers and users of land or water whose interests may differ from those of the project developer.

AreaEvidence to request
Land and livelihoodsTenure and access arrangements, the groups consulted and the response to any contested access
Biodiversity and waterBaseline conditions, expected changes, monitoring results and action where adverse effects appear
Workers and contractorsSafety procedures, access to reporting channels and follow-up on recorded incidents
Participation and grievancesAccessible consultation records, a route for complaints and evidence that someone is responsible for responses

Table 3, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Area
Land and livelihoods
Evidence to request
Tenure and access arrangements, the groups consulted and the response to any contested access

Row 2

Area
Biodiversity and water
Evidence to request
Baseline conditions, expected changes, monitoring results and action where adverse effects appear

Row 3

Area
Workers and contractors
Evidence to request
Safety procedures, access to reporting channels and follow-up on recorded incidents

Row 4

Area
Participation and grievances
Evidence to request
Accessible consultation records, a route for complaints and evidence that someone is responsible for responses

Review affected people and ecosystems as well as the carbon evidence.
Review affected people and ecosystems as well as the carbon evidence.
Diagram text description

Check land and livelihoods, including access and the treatment of workers. For ecosystems, inspect biodiversity and water effects. Match each check to the project’s activities and identify who will investigate and respond to a credible unresolved issue.

Match the evidence to the activity. A project that restricts access to grazing land needs to show how affected users could participate and what happened when they raised a concern. A signature sheet establishes attendance. Ask for evidence of the issue raised, the response and any follow-up. Where the relevant rules require consent, ask the reviewer to verify how it was sought and documented.

Treat a credible unresolved allegation of harm as an issue requiring investigation. Name the owner and decision deadline, and use a hold where the buyer cannot establish that a critical safeguard is met.

Use a scored due-diligence table

Consider this fictional example. Ordel Instruments compares two offers for a voluntary contribution programme. The names, documents and scores are invented. Ordel’s rule is to record 2 for evidence that meets its stated test, 1 for partial evidence and 0 for a missing or contradicted requirement. It logs the reason with each score. There is no total.

Review areaBrindle capture offerSkell grassland offer
Issuance and delivery2. Issuance extract matches the vintage and serial range in the offer.2. Batch and offered subrange match the issuance extract.
Additionality and baseline0. A site permit requires the same capture activity during the offered period. The file gives no basis for crediting activity beyond that obligation.2. The file contains the adoption assessment, comparable land-use evidence and conservative baseline assumptions for the offered period.
Measurement and durability2. Meter checks and the independent report cover the claimed period.1. The verification report covers the vintage. The file lacks the current monitoring responsibilities and reversal response plan.
Safeguards2. The offer supplies the site review and follow-up on worker concerns.1. Meeting notes document a disputed access restriction. The file lacks the project’s response and evidence of follow-up.
Delivery and proposed use2. The contract sets out exact delivery references and retirement instructions for the intended beneficiary.2. The seller identifies the retirement account and agrees to use Ordel’s legal name and contribution purpose.

Table 4, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Review area
Issuance and delivery
Brindle capture offer
2. Issuance extract matches the vintage and serial range in the offer.
Skell grassland offer
2. Batch and offered subrange match the issuance extract.

Row 2

Review area
Additionality and baseline
Brindle capture offer
0. A site permit requires the same capture activity during the offered period. The file gives no basis for crediting activity beyond that obligation.
Skell grassland offer
2. The file contains the adoption assessment, comparable land-use evidence and conservative baseline assumptions for the offered period.

Row 3

Review area
Measurement and durability
Brindle capture offer
2. Meter checks and the independent report cover the claimed period.
Skell grassland offer
1. The verification report covers the vintage. The file lacks the current monitoring responsibilities and reversal response plan.

Row 4

Review area
Safeguards
Brindle capture offer
2. The offer supplies the site review and follow-up on worker concerns.
Skell grassland offer
1. Meeting notes document a disputed access restriction. The file lacks the project’s response and evidence of follow-up.

Row 5

Review area
Delivery and proposed use
Brindle capture offer
2. The contract sets out exact delivery references and retirement instructions for the intended beneficiary.
Skell grassland offer
2. The seller identifies the retirement account and agrees to use Ordel’s legal name and contribution purpose.

Ordel stops the Brindle purchase under its policy on mandatory activity. The matching serials and meter evidence do not clear the additionality failure. Ordel holds Skell. Its project reviewer requests the monitoring and reversal documents, and its safeguards reviewer asks who was affected by the access restriction and what remedy was agreed. Procurement holds authorisation until both reviewers record a decision.

Ordel stops Brindle and holds Skell for two unresolved reviews.
Ordel stops Brindle and holds Skell for two unresolved reviews.
Diagram text description

The fictional Brindle capture activity was required by its site permit and Ordel stops the purchase under its rule. Skell remains on hold for the current monitoring and reversal arrangements and the safeguards response to disputed access. Ordel uses evidence status for each area with no total.

Define these gates before offers are scored. Treat an unresolved entitlement to the units, a missing basis for additionality or a material unresolved safeguard as a reason to hold or stop. Apply the gates individually, preserve contrary evidence and record who can clear a hold. The numbers help a team compare the strength of its files. Programme certification and the buyer’s purchase approval remain separate decisions.

Retire the right units for the right claim

First identify the exact units and confirm who can instruct the retirement. Match the completed registry action to the batch, beneficiary and purpose before reviewing the statement. An invoice supports the purchase record. Use the registry action to establish retirement, which removes those units from further use under the programme’s rules.

The diagram follows the records in order. If a seller retires the units on the buyer’s behalf, check both the authority to act and how the beneficiary is recorded. Verify the particular fields available under the programme and keep the completed record with the approved wording.

Match serials and authority, retain the retirement record, then review wording.
Match serials and authority, retain the retirement record, then review wording.
Diagram text description

Match the exact issued units and confirm who can act on them. Verify the completed registry action and the named beneficiary and record it once. Review the proposed period, purpose and wording against those records.

Consider this fictional example. In a separate purchase from the two offers above, Ordel Instruments receives 100 units from project FIC-214, vintage 2023, in the invented Arven programme. The transfer record lists FIC-7001 through FIC-7100 in Ordel’s authorised account. The account holder receives an instruction to retire 70 units for Ordel Instruments Ltd’s 2025 voluntary contribution programme.

The fictional retirement record AR-884 shows FIC-7001 through FIC-7070 retired on 8 April 2026. It names Ordel Instruments Ltd and records the stated contribution purpose. The remaining 30 units, FIC-7071 through FIC-7100, are still held. Procurement checks the two serial ranges for overlap, reconciles them to the 100 delivered and keeps the retirement record with the approved instruction.

The documented statement is “Ordel Instruments Ltd retired 70 credits for its 2025 voluntary contribution programme.” It describes a particular transaction, entity and use. Retiring the 70 units in 2026 does not change their 2023 vintage or establish the emissions of Ordel’s products in 2025. An organisation-wide neutrality statement would need a separate basis, including evidence about the organisation’s emissions boundary and the rules that apply to the claim.

Keep the emissions record and credit record separate

Keep the emissions record and credit record in separate files. The emissions file should show the entity or product, boundary, period and underlying activity data. For a product this may include a revision of the bill of materials, supplier inputs, conversion factors and the method used to calculate the footprint. Record the versions so a reviewer can reproduce the stated figure when a supplier input changes.

The credit file should keep the project and monitoring material, the batch and transaction records, any retirement and the beneficiary. Track operational reductions in the emissions file with the evidence of what changed inside its boundary. Keep external transactions visible as credit activity when a statement refers to both.

Keep the emissions evidence and the external credit evidence in separate files.
Keep the emissions evidence and the external credit evidence in separate files.
Diagram text description

The emissions file retains product and boundary, SKU and BOM, supplier data, period and operational changes. The credit file retains project method, batch and transaction evidence, registry retirement and beneficiary. A wording review can inspect both files without netting their quantities.

For Ordel, the retirement is linked to its 2025 contribution programme. A product footprint for a component introduced in that year would still need records for the component, its suppliers and its production period. At wording review, ask what each file actually supports, then attach the records to the approved sentence. Review the wording again when either file changes in a way that affects the sentence.

Decide whether to proceed, hold or stop

Before approving a purchase, match the exact units to the independent assessment, then decide whether the project evidence, safeguards and proposed use meet the buyer’s written criteria. Give any material gap to someone who can obtain the source record and leave the decision on hold while it is unresolved. Where the evidence conflicts with a critical requirement, record the reason for stopping.

Keep the completed due-diligence comparison with the purchase decision. If the approved use involves retirement, match the completed transaction and beneficiary to the intended wording and keep the result with the statement. Record any units still held separately. When a credit statement sits beside an emissions figure, check the emissions file on its own terms. This gives the next reviewer a record of which facts support the words and which decisions need to be reopened.