Two fictional unbranded notebooks with paper materials and a circular life-cycle motif; no measured impact claim.
Notebook designs are compared for the writing service they provide.
Diagram text description

Synthetic editorial illustration introducing a notebook inventory comparison; it does not depict measured environmental impacts.

A lighter notebook is not necessarily the better environmental choice. If it supplies fewer usable pages, a buyer may need more notebooks to deliver the same writing service. A useful product life cycle assessment starts by making that service equal, then follows the materials, production, delivery, use and disposal associated with it.

This inventory-stage worked example compares two fictional notebook designs. It does not calculate environmental impact indicators or complete a quantified LCA. We will calculate the number of notebooks and the material quantities needed for the same task, then change one assumption to see what happens. That gives the example a practical result: a comparison that a product team can build on, rather than two unrelated weights on a supplier sheet.

All quantities below are teaching inputs, not measurements from a Carbon Loop customer. The example follows a purchasing question from equal service to component quantities and a sensitivity test, so each calculation has a clear role in the decision.

Define the writing service before counting notebooks

Suppose a purchasing team needs 12,000 usable writing pages for a programme. In our fictional specification, design A delivers 100 usable pages per notebook and design B delivers 150. The comparison therefore requires 120 A notebooks or 80 B notebooks. Those quantities are the reference flows: the physical products needed to deliver the chosen service.

The calculation is straightforward: required service divided by service per product. For A, 12,000 ÷ 100 = 120 notebooks. For B, 12,000 ÷ 150 = 80 notebooks. Comparing one A against one B would give the second design fifty per cent more writing capacity, so it would answer a different purchasing question.

“Usable” needs a practical definition. Pages supplied are not necessarily pages used. A notebook left in a drawer still required materials and manufacturing, even if it contributed little to the programme. In a real study, the team would describe the user group, period and expected use, then decide how to observe or estimate service delivered. Our starting case assumes full use so that the arithmetic remains easy to follow; we test lower use later.

The functional unit must also fit the purpose. If the purchase is a one-time gift to 120 people, giving everyone a notebook may be part of the function. Eighty larger notebooks would not serve that requirement. Resolve that choice before modelling: equal page capacity and equal distribution to recipients are not automatically the same service.

Equal writing capacity needs different quantities of the two designs.
Equal writing capacity needs different quantities of the two designs.
Diagram text description

For the fictional 12,000-page requirement, divide by 100 usable pages per A notebook to obtain 120 notebooks, or by 150 per B notebook to obtain 80. Both routes deliver the same writing capacity.

Compare designs within the same boundary

Design A has a lighter cover and fewer pages. Design B has a heavier cover and more pages. Both include paper, a cover and binding, and both require printing, packaging and delivery. Treat these as alternative specifications for the same task, not as shorthand for “basic” and “sustainable.”

Follow each design through equivalent stages: raw-material supply, paper and cover manufacture, conversion into a finished notebook, delivery, use and eventual collection or disposal. Shared processes belong in both models on a consistent basis. A comparison that includes delivery for A but stops at the factory gate for B would mix boundaries and make the totals difficult to interpret.

There is room for sensible simplification. A screening study can concentrate effort on influential or uncertain flows, provided the scope and exclusions are clear. For example, identical artwork does not necessarily mean identical printing activity if one design uses a different cover material or process. Ask whether the assumed similarity is physical, merely visual, or supported by production information.

The boundary also defines who supplies the data. The notebook converter may know printing electricity and scrap, while the paper supplier holds upstream production information. Freight information may sit with purchasing or logistics. Assigning those responsibilities early makes the study easier to complete: the team can request the missing piece from its owner instead of repeatedly asking one supplier for the entire life cycle.

Calculate the material inventory

Give each fictional design a simple component specification. A contains 200 grams of paper, a 30-gram cover and 10 grams of binding. B contains 300 grams of paper, a 60-gram cover and 15 grams of binding. These are illustrative masses chosen to show how the reference flow changes a comparison.

Component A: grams per notebook A: 120 notebooks B: grams per notebook B: 80 notebooks
Paper 200 24.0 kg 300 24.0 kg
Cover 30 3.6 kg 60 4.8 kg
Binding 10 1.2 kg 15 1.2 kg
Total 240 28.8 kg 375 30.0 kg

For A’s paper, 200 g × 120 = 24,000 g, or 24 kg. Repeating that calculation for every component produces the inventory above. Although each B notebook is heavier, fewer are needed; the difference across the whole service is 1.2 kg, concentrated in the cover. The paper and binding totals are equal in this deliberately simple starting case.

That is already more informative than comparing 240 grams with 375 grams. It shows which component deserves attention next. It also leaves important work visible: the table does not include process scrap, energy, packaging or transport. If production consumes extra material that does not reach the finished product, add that input and its treatment separately rather than assuming the finished mass is the entire production requirement.

For a real inventory, replace each teaching input with the exact product specification and the appropriate production data. Keep units beside quantities, particularly when converting grams to kilograms or allocating a batch total across products. A small unit error can overwhelm the difference we are trying to understand.

The finished-material difference is 1.2 kg for equal page capacity.
The finished-material difference is 1.2 kg for equal page capacity.
Diagram text description

Illustrative finished-material totals: A uses 28.8 kg and B uses 30.0 kg. The bars share a zero baseline and their lengths are proportional to those totals. They show material mass, not environmental impact.

Turn inventory quantities into impact indicators

The inventory describes what the system uses and releases. Impact assessment translates relevant flows into indicators using appropriate data and characterisation methods. Material mass alone is not an environmental score: two paper supplies can have different production processes, energy inputs and geographic conditions even when their delivered weights match.

Climate change is one possible indicator. Other categories may reveal different effects or trade-offs. Their units and meanings differ, so adding a climate result to a water-related indicator would not produce a meaningful total. Present each category in its proper terms and explain what drives it.

In the notebook example, the next modelling task is to associate the included materials and processes with suitable data. That means checking the match between the actual material and dataset, the production technology, geography, period and treatment of shared processes. A generic number can be useful for an early screen, but its suitability depends on the question and the decision it supports.

We can therefore say that B uses 1.2 kg more finished material in the starting inventory. We cannot say that it has a larger carbon footprint or worse overall environmental performance. Its cover material, production route or other lifecycle stages could change the result. The benefit of the inventory is that it makes the next investigation specific: establish the cover differences and the omitted processes, then calculate category indicators on a consistent basis.

Test what happens when pages go unused

Now change one assumption while keeping the required service at 12,000 usable pages. Suppose only 80 of A’s 100 pages are used on average, while all 150 pages of B are used. A now requires 150 notebooks: 12,000 ÷ 80. B still requires 80. This is an illustrative sensitivity scenario, not a prediction about user behaviour.

Result Starting case Lower use of A
A notebooks required 120 150
A finished material 28.8 kg 36.0 kg
B notebooks required 80 80
B finished material 30.0 kg 30.0 kg

The material comparison reverses. A started 1.2 kg below B; it is now 6 kg above B. Nothing about the per-notebook specification changed. The change comes entirely from the number needed to deliver the function. This demonstrates why actual use can be more informative than a small weight reduction.

The scenario deliberately changes only A’s utilisation. A balanced study would examine credible use assumptions for both designs and propagate them through the model. It might also test paper sourcing, conversion losses or delivery arrangements if those inputs are uncertain and influential.

Use sensitivity analysis to decide where better information is worth collecting. If a modest change in utilisation alters the comparison, a small user trial may be more valuable than refining a minor packaging estimate. If the conclusion stays similar across plausible scenarios, the team can explain why it has greater confidence in that particular decision.

We can also find the material break-even point in this simplified case. Each A notebook contains 0.24 kg of finished material. Matching B’s 30 kg total therefore permits 30 ÷ 0.24 = 125 A notebooks. To supply 12,000 usable pages with 125 notebooks, each must deliver 96 usable pages on average. Below that utilisation, A’s finished material total exceeds B’s; above it, the total is lower, with B still assumed to deliver all its pages.

This threshold gives the user trial a focused question: is average use plausibly above or below 96 pages? It is more helpful than asking whether recipients generally like the lighter notebook. Use the 96-page threshold to design the observation: record usable pages delivered per notebook over the programme, including notebooks distributed but left unused.

Lower utilisation increases the number of A notebooks required.
Lower utilisation increases the number of A notebooks required.
Diagram text description

The fictional service stays at 12,000 usable pages. At 100 usable pages per A notebook, 120 notebooks are required. At 80 usable pages each, 150 are required, giving 36 kg of finished material instead of 28.8 kg.

Decide what conclusion the study can support

The worked example supports two clear conclusions about its own assumptions. First, equal writing service requires different product quantities. Second, utilisation can change the direction of a material comparison. Those are useful findings even though no environmental impact result has been calculated.

For an internal design discussion, this may be enough to choose the next investigation: test page use, obtain cover specifications or request production data. The decision is about what to learn or develop next. It is different from telling customers that one notebook has a lower environmental impact.

A public comparison needs a study designed for that purpose, with suitable scope, data, reporting and review. Agree the intended statement before commissioning the work. A narrow carbon assessment and a broader lifecycle assessment answer different questions, and neither should acquire a stronger claim simply because the result is presented in an attractive chart.

Keep the conclusion proportionate to the evidence. “Design A uses less finished material under full utilisation” is a precise statement about this scenario. “Design A is greener” would discard the functional assumptions, the missing processes and the distinction between mass and impact. Good communication keeps the useful finding while making its meaning easy to understand.

Commission a real comparison in a practical order

Start with a short study brief that both purchasing and the practitioner can use. It should identify the decision, intended audience, product versions and functional service. Attach the specifications for the two alternatives so the study begins with a definite comparison rather than a general request for sustainability information.

  1. Agree the function and reference flows. Explain how the products will be distributed and used, and which assumptions need observation.
  2. Confirm equivalent boundaries. Identify the material, manufacturing, delivery, use and end-of-life stages included for each design.
  3. Build the inventory. Collect component quantities, production inputs, losses, packaging and transport information from the relevant owners.
  4. Select suitable modelling data and methods. Resolve material matching, shared-process allocation and significant missing information.
  5. Interpret the results. Test influential assumptions, explain category-specific differences and check whether the intended conclusion follows.

The sequence is iterative. A result may reveal that a supposedly minor component is influential, or that the original service definition does not represent actual purchasing. Revisiting an earlier choice is part of doing the study well, not evidence that the project has failed.

Set a useful handoff at each stage. A completed inventory should identify what is included and which inputs remain provisional. An interpretation should explain why the proposed decision holds, where it is sensitive and what would require an update. This helps the team spend its effort on the choices that affect the outcome.

Prepare one product record that the team can use

Before expanding the exercise across a catalogue, build one coherent record for a real notebook. Place the product identifier, dated specification, component list and supplier information together. Add the production period and the expected distribution and use conditions. The aim is a usable starting point for the practitioner, not a large folder of loosely related documents.

Consider a practical mismatch: the purchasing sheet specifies one paper grade, while a sample weight comes from a later version with a different cover. Combining those files would create a product that was never actually supplied. Resolve the version difference before entering the quantities, then keep the alternative as a separate scenario if it is relevant to the decision.

For this notebook comparison, a compact record might look like this:

Field Entry to resolve before modelling
Product version Ordered notebook code, specification date and matching sample
Service Usable pages over the named programme, with distribution requirements
Component masses Paper, cover and binding measured on the same product version
Conversion losses Purchased input and finished output for the relevant production batch
Use observation Pages used per distributed notebook, including unused notebooks
Open decision Whether improved use or a different cover deserves the next trial

Keep the product identifier on each supporting file. If the cover changes after sampling, retain the earlier record as a separate scenario and update the affected quantities. The record then explains what changed, rather than leaving the practitioner to reconcile incompatible specifications.

For the first comparison, choose a product with accessible specifications and a decision someone is ready to make. That gives the work a practical destination: select a design for further testing, identify a priority data gap or decide whether a more complete assessment is worthwhile. The same structure can later support other products without copying their assumptions.

Use the example to make the next decision

The notebook comparison begins with equal writing service and ends with a better question. Under full utilisation, A needs 120 notebooks and B needs 80; their finished material totals are 28.8 kg and 30 kg. When A delivers only 80 usable pages per notebook, its requirement rises to 150 notebooks and 36 kg. Those differences explain where further evidence could change the purchasing decision.

The next step is to replace the teaching assumptions with a real product specification and realistic use information, then model the included lifecycle processes with suitable data. Use the 96-page threshold to focus the first observation, and the cover difference to focus the first supplier data request.

A useful LCA example makes the reasoning visible. It shows how a function becomes product quantities, how those quantities become an inventory, and how assumptions influence the comparison. That is the part to carry into a real brief: a clearly defined decision, comparable alternatives and a focused plan for finding the answer.