A tabletop shows plain and printed totes, bottles, a blue screen-printing frame and an open shipping carton.
Blank products, branding and shipping each have a place in the order record.
Diagram text description

Plain and printed fabric totes lie beside metal bottles, a blue screen-printing frame, paper packing and an open carton. A small route illustration sits nearby. The scene illustrates the stages of a branded merchandise order.

A merchandise carbon figure can describe a supplier's blank item, a decorated product or an order delivered to its recipients. Start with the supplier's declared stages and count only the additional work the order requires. Decoration, rejects, added packing and split shipments can all change the order total.

Set the handover point before using the blank figure. In the worked example, the supplier's value already reaches the decorator and includes bulk protection and inbound freight. The order adds the print work, new packing and onward delivery. A second supplier's factory-gate value ends earlier and needs a separate inbound record before the two options can be compared.

The delivered subtotal includes the supplier blank through decorator receipt plus decoration, packing and delivery. Customer use and product end of life are separate stages.
Extend the blank-item boundary with order activities through delivery.
Diagram text description

The frame shows a delivered-order subtotal. The blank arrives at the decorator with its supplier stages already included. Add the decoration, packing and delivery activities outside that supplier record. Customer use and product end of life sit beyond this order boundary.

The delivered subtotal stops at receipt. Customer use and product end of life need their own scenarios for a complete final-product study. The GHG Protocol Product Standard treats the full final-product boundary as extending through end of life. For a buying decision focused on delivery, keep the narrower scope visible beside both the order total and the result per accepted item.

Decide what the carbon number describes

Choose the unit that matches the question. Ask whether the number describes one blank received at a named point, one accepted decorated item before dispatch, or the complete delivery order. A quotation may use the word “item” for any of those, even though each carries a different set of activities.

BasisWhat the number describesUse it to answer
One blank item receivedA specific supplier SKU and revision up to the declared receiving pointWhat supplier value can I use as the starting input?
One accepted decorated itemThe blank and attributable branding work, including the batch effort and losses, up to the stated decoration gateWhat does the production choice add before onward fulfilment?
One delivered campaign orderAll attributable included stages for the stated accepted quantity and delivery planWhat is the order subtotal and its average per accepted delivered item?

Table 1, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Basis
One blank item received
What the number describes
A specific supplier SKU and revision up to the declared receiving point
Use it to answer
What supplier value can I use as the starting input?

Row 2

Basis
One accepted decorated item
What the number describes
The blank and attributable branding work, including the batch effort and losses, up to the stated decoration gate
Use it to answer
What does the production choice add before onward fulfilment?

Row 3

Basis
One delivered campaign order
What the number describes
All attributable included stages for the stated accepted quantity and delivery plan
Use it to answer
What is the order subtotal and its average per accepted delivered item?

Write both the input count and the output count. The supplier factor applies to each blank consumed. The decorated average divides by accepted output once the batch activities are attributed. If accepted items are damaged in transit, reconcile what the recipient actually accepts and any replacement deliveries before closing the delivered count.

A delivered average describes the route mix for the whole order. It can help a buyer compare the same service under compatible boundaries. A parcel recipient and a venue recipient may have different logistics burdens, so retain the route records if the team needs figures for those groups.

Start with the blank product record

Use a supplier estimate only after matching it to the blank the order will actually consume. A catalogue name may cover different component masses, manufacturing sites or revisions. Check the order code and specification against the underlying product record and ask what the supplier value includes.

  • Confirm the exact SKU, revision, factory and data period. Match the supplied blank to the purchase and receipt records.
  • Ask for the bill of materials, component masses and evidence for any recycled-content inputs used. Identify the manufacturing processes and upstream material data behind the figure.
  • Record the declared unit, scope and factor or calculation method. Ask which production losses, supplier packaging, freight legs and other processes are included and where the reported boundary ends.
  • Identify the data owner and the inputs that are measured, estimated or based on a proxy. Keep the factor version, applicable geography and review status with the value.

Draw the supplier boundary around the stages actually counted. If the figure includes bulk wrapping and transport to the decorator, carry those stages in the blank value once. Keep the later outbound packs and transport records separate. If the supplier provides only a factory-gate value, request the next leg rather than assuming the decorator has already received the product in the calculation.

Use the BOM to check that the quote matches the order. Adding every component's emissions to an estimate that already includes those materials would count the same activities twice.

Add the work that makes it branded

Decoration starts with the artwork and the method used on the actual order. A print, embroidery or transfer job can use different consumables and energy even on the same blank. Record the artwork coverage, process, quantity and quality criterion before interpreting a decorator's average.

For a screen-print order, log the artwork and screens, the preparation work, the printing run, ink used and accepted and rejected counts. Setup can include test work, cleaning and power before the main run. The run can include printing and curing. Keep the metered setup interval and the run interval separate. If a supplier gives a total that already covers both, use that total once and disclose the split only if the records support it.

A rejected tote consumed its blank and whatever decoration inputs were used before rejection. Charge those inputs to the order once through the consumed blank count and the print records. Track collection and treatment of the rejects as a separate activity if the stage boundary includes it. Separate test blanks, rejected items and process waste in the log so every item or material can be reconciled.

Prefer records specific to the order. The GHG Protocol's allocation guidance favours separating common processes where feasible and using a defensible physical basis when they must be shared. For a shared press, a separately metered run is stronger than a share of the shop's monthly electricity. If a split is needed, record the physical driver and why it fits the actual process.

Finish the order with packaging and delivery

This worked order is fictional. Seabank Field Day orders 240 accepted cotton canvas totes, SKU CT-17 revision C, with one screen-printed design. In Arrangement A, the assumed supplier estimate of 1.60 kg CO2e per blank includes materials, manufacture, bulk protective wrapping and delivery to the decorator. Every quantity and factor below is invented for the exercise.

The decorator prints 250 blanks. Ten fail inspection and 240 are accepted and delivered. All 240 packed totes share a transfer from the decorator to a dispatch hub. From the hub, 180 go to one venue in 12 bulk cartons and 60 go to individual recipients in 60 parcels. Keep the common transfer record separate from the venue and parcel records. Each route has its own packing count and carrier basis.

Of 250 printed blanks, 240 are accepted and delivered and 10 are rejected. Of the accepted totes, 180 go to the venue and 60 go by parcel.
Charge all 250 printed blanks to the order and divide its subtotal by 240 accepted deliveries.
Diagram text description

This fictional print batch consumes 250 blanks. The order carries the blank and printing inputs for all 250. Ten rejects stay out of delivered quantities. Of the 240 accepted totes, 180 go to one venue and 60 travel as individual parcels. The per-delivered-unit calculation uses 240 as its denominator.

StageFictional activity × factorkg CO2e for order
Blank through decorator receipt250 blanks × 1.60 kg CO2e per blank400.00
Print run electricity30 kWh × 0.40 kg CO2e per kWh12.00
Print ink1.00 kg × 5.00 kg CO2e per kg ink5.00
Setup electricity5 kWh × 0.40 kg CO2e per kWh2.00
Setup wipes0.50 kg × 2.00 kg CO2e per kg wipes, including their treatment1.00
Reject treatment2.50 kg of printed rejects × 0.40 kg CO2e per kg treated1.00
Venue packing12 cartons × 0.50 kg CO2e per carton6.00
Individual packing60 packs × 0.15 kg CO2e per pack9.00
Decorator to dispatch hub10 tonne-km × 0.40 kg CO2e per tonne-km4.00
Hub to venue20 tonne-km × 0.40 kg CO2e per tonne-km8.00
Hub to parcel recipients60 parcels × 0.25 kg CO2e per parcel15.00
Included delivered-order subtotalSum of the stage results463.00

Table 2, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Stage
Blank through decorator receipt
Fictional activity × factor
250 blanks × 1.60 kg CO2e per blank
kg CO2e for order
400.00

Row 2

Stage
Print run electricity
Fictional activity × factor
30 kWh × 0.40 kg CO2e per kWh
kg CO2e for order
12.00

Row 3

Stage
Print ink
Fictional activity × factor
1.00 kg × 5.00 kg CO2e per kg ink
kg CO2e for order
5.00

Row 4

Stage
Setup electricity
Fictional activity × factor
5 kWh × 0.40 kg CO2e per kWh
kg CO2e for order
2.00

Row 5

Stage
Setup wipes
Fictional activity × factor
0.50 kg × 2.00 kg CO2e per kg wipes, including their treatment
kg CO2e for order
1.00

Row 6

Stage
Reject treatment
Fictional activity × factor
2.50 kg of printed rejects × 0.40 kg CO2e per kg treated
kg CO2e for order
1.00

Row 7

Stage
Venue packing
Fictional activity × factor
12 cartons × 0.50 kg CO2e per carton
kg CO2e for order
6.00

Row 8

Stage
Individual packing
Fictional activity × factor
60 packs × 0.15 kg CO2e per pack
kg CO2e for order
9.00

Row 9

Stage
Decorator to dispatch hub
Fictional activity × factor
10 tonne-km × 0.40 kg CO2e per tonne-km
kg CO2e for order
4.00

Row 10

Stage
Hub to venue
Fictional activity × factor
20 tonne-km × 0.40 kg CO2e per tonne-km
kg CO2e for order
8.00

Row 11

Stage
Hub to parcel recipients
Fictional activity × factor
60 parcels × 0.25 kg CO2e per parcel
kg CO2e for order
15.00

Row 12

Stage
Included delivered-order subtotal
Fictional activity × factor
Sum of the stage results
kg CO2e for order
463.00

The setup and run electricity intervals are separate. The 30 kWh covers the print run for all 250, including rejects. Assume the ink is consumed in that run and the wipes factor includes the separate wipe waste. The reject treatment row charges only collection and treatment of the 2.50 kg reject batch. The blanks and print effort for those rejects are already in the input rows.

These activities are assigned to this one order. The tonne-km values represent the shipment mass carried over each named distance, already attributed to the order. The parcel rate covers its route from the hub through delivery. The shared transfer belongs in the total once, and the exercise assumes no separately attributable storage or handling beyond the stated services. Keep any real omitted operations on the scope record.

The arithmetic closes as 250 = 240 accepted + 10 rejected and 240 = 180 venue + 60 parcel. Divide 463.00 kg CO2e by 240 accepted delivered totes to obtain about 1.93 kg CO2e per accepted delivered tote. The division spreads this order's attributable included activities across its accepted output. It is a delivered subtotal with customer use and product end of life outside the scope.

Arrangement B has an unresolved inbound leg from the supplier's factory gate to the decorator. Hold the A/B ranking until that stage is evidenced and both estimates use compatible assumptions. Keep Arrangement A's scoped subtotal available for internal screening while the shortlist remains open.

Treat lifetime as an assumption, not a slogan

A tote's usable life depends on whether people keep it, use it and replace it, and how they care for it. A delivered subtotal ends before those behaviours. If the buyer wants a per-use or complete life-cycle comparison, define the service and collect evidence about what recipients do after delivery.

In a low-use scenario, a bag may be stored or discarded after a few trips, so its production and delivery burden is spread across relatively little service. In a high-use scenario, the bag may complete many trips. Include any washing, drying, repair or replacement expected in that scenario. A longer use period can spread the initial burden and add care impacts. Both scenarios need retention and care evidence, and their effect depends on the same defined service.

Ask what would count as successful use. A comparison between bags with different carrying capacities or durability needs a shared carrying function. Test what happens if fewer recipients keep the item or if cleaning is more frequent than expected. Keep the count assumptions visible alongside any per-use estimate.

For the Seabank procurement question, the exercise holds the accepted order and delivery destinations fixed. A study of recipient behaviour would answer a further question and would need its own boundary, use records and treatment assumptions.

Why two disclosed figures may not be comparable

Before reading two figures as a ranking, check that they describe the same delivered function and comparable stages. A common unit name can hide different starting quantities, excluded legs or methods.

  • Match the product revision, function, quality criterion, order quantity and accepted delivered unit.
  • Trace the start and end of each blank value. Reconcile decoration, rejects, packing, freight, use and treatment to the same intended boundary.
  • Check the year, site and geographic coverage of activity data and factors. Ask whether each route and manufacturing site is represented.
  • Compare factor provenance and method, including treatment of shared processes and important proxies. Keep uncertainty and review status beside the figures.

For example, a lower factory-gate amount can become higher once it is brought to the decorator. A buyer can record both values with their endpoints and request the missing leg. If they cannot align the underlying methods or material inputs, keep a separate uncertainty note even after the freight is reconciled.

The GHG Protocol's publisher guidance distinguishes hotspot work from product comparisons that may need more specific rules. For a real shortlist, agree on the method and acceptance conditions before treating a numerical difference as decisive.

What industry campaign figures can and cannot prove

Industry channel research can help a campaign team decide where to ask better questions. A trade-association study using sampled distributor sales and modelling can compare media channels directionally within its own assumptions. The unit, sales mix, modelled behaviour and distribution routes define what that evidence can support.

Bring the discussion back to the item and order if a buyer needs a figure for a particular tote, bottle or kit. Request the actual SKU revision, blank scope, decoration method, packing and shipment records. The channel study addresses a different unit of analysis. Its result cannot fill an order's missing carrier leg or establish an independently assured product result.

Keep the evidence in separate records. A directional channel result can justify investigating a change in campaign design. A decision to compare two merchandise orders needs their own compatible boundaries and input records. That distinction lets the buyer use the research without extending it to an unsupported SKU claim.

Ask suppliers for a practical evidence pack

Send an evidence request that follows the order from supplier to decorator, packer and carrier. Ask each party for the records it controls and name one owner to reconcile the boundaries. A total without its stages can leave the buyer unsure which additional rows belong in the calculation.

  • Supplier. Confirm the SKU, revision, declared unit, BOM inputs, site, data period, method and included blank stages. State exactly where the delivery boundary ends.
  • Decorator. Provide the artwork and process record, separate setup and run energy where available, consumable quantities, accepted and rejected counts, and waste treatment.
  • Packer and fulfilment owner. List packaging already included, incremental packs, quantities per route and the handover points.
  • Carrier. Identify mode, shipment basis, legs, destinations, distance or parcel counts, and what is included in any rate.
  • Calculation owner. Record factor sources and versions, data gaps, proxies, allocation method, assurance scope and reviewer. Name the update trigger for changes in supplier, revision, artwork, quantities or route.

Give every open item a next step. For Arrangement B, ask the supplier or inbound carrier for the factory-to-decorator activity and its factor basis. Keep the gap distinct from the transport already included in Arrangement A. If a record cannot be supplied, retain the affected stage and the decision that remains on hold. This gives procurement a concrete follow-up rather than a general request for more sustainability data.

Make a like-for-like merchandise shortlist

This fictional comparison uses the same Seabank order. Both arrangements must supply 240 accepted CT-17 revision C totes of the same carrying and print quality. Both deliver 180 to the same venue and 60 to the same individual addresses. The model keeps the blank input count, print, setup, waste and packing assumptions fixed except for the supplier's stated blank boundary.

CheckArrangement A, dispatch hubArrangement B, direct handoff
Blank inputs and boundary250 × 1.60 kg CO2e = 400.00 kg CO2e through decorator receipt250 × 1.55 kg CO2e = 387.50 kg CO2e. Same defined production and protective wrapping stages through the factory gate. Inbound activity and factor are missing.
Shared decoration and packing assumption36.00 kg CO2e for the run, ink, setup, wipes, reject treatment and both packaging streamsSame 36.00 kg CO2e for the same order inputs in the exercise
Outbound freight4.00 shared transfer + 8.00 venue + 15.00 parcel = 27.00 kg CO2eDirect venue leg of 15 tonne-km × 0.40 = 6.00 kg CO2e. Direct parcels of 60 × 0.30 = 18.00 kg CO2e. Total 24.00 kg CO2e.
Known subtotal and unit basis463.00 kg CO2e ÷ 240 = about 1.93 kg CO2e per accepted delivered tote447.50 kg CO2e ÷ 240 = about 1.86 kg CO2e per accepted tote for known stages only
Shortlist decisionRetain the scoped subtotal for screening and confirm the evidence qualityHold rank pending inbound evidence and compatible supplier methods. Sensitivity threshold is 15.50 kg CO2e for the missing leg.

Table 3, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Check
Blank inputs and boundary
Arrangement A, dispatch hub
250 × 1.60 kg CO2e = 400.00 kg CO2e through decorator receipt
Arrangement B, direct handoff
250 × 1.55 kg CO2e = 387.50 kg CO2e. Same defined production and protective wrapping stages through the factory gate. Inbound activity and factor are missing.

Row 2

Check
Shared decoration and packing assumption
Arrangement A, dispatch hub
36.00 kg CO2e for the run, ink, setup, wipes, reject treatment and both packaging streams
Arrangement B, direct handoff
Same 36.00 kg CO2e for the same order inputs in the exercise

Row 3

Check
Outbound freight
Arrangement A, dispatch hub
4.00 shared transfer + 8.00 venue + 15.00 parcel = 27.00 kg CO2e
Arrangement B, direct handoff
Direct venue leg of 15 tonne-km × 0.40 = 6.00 kg CO2e. Direct parcels of 60 × 0.30 = 18.00 kg CO2e. Total 24.00 kg CO2e.

Row 4

Check
Known subtotal and unit basis
Arrangement A, dispatch hub
463.00 kg CO2e ÷ 240 = about 1.93 kg CO2e per accepted delivered tote
Arrangement B, direct handoff
447.50 kg CO2e ÷ 240 = about 1.86 kg CO2e per accepted tote for known stages only

Row 5

Check
Shortlist decision
Arrangement A, dispatch hub
Retain the scoped subtotal for screening and confirm the evidence quality
Arrangement B, direct handoff
Hold rank pending inbound evidence and compatible supplier methods. Sensitivity threshold is 15.50 kg CO2e for the missing leg.

The 36.00 kg CO2e common block uses the order's own setup, run, waste and pack records. B replaces the outbound route as a whole, so its direct rates already start at the decorator. The unrecorded leg is upstream of that handoff. Treat it as missing data within the desired delivered boundary.

The arithmetic difference is 463.00 − 447.50 = 15.50 kg CO2e. If all other inputs stay fixed and comparable, an inbound contribution below that amount would preserve B's lower number, the same amount would tie and a larger contribution would reverse the order. The fictional record supplies no value for the leg. Ask for the shipment basis, distance, mode and factor and verify that the blank calculations use compatible period, geography and methods before ranking the arrangements.

Do not turn an estimate into a verified claim

Decide the intended use before sharing the number. An internal shortlist can keep an estimate with its stage limits, input assumptions and open questions. The buyer can compare what is known, identify the next evidence request and make the status clear to the people deciding the order.

For internal screening, keep the source, data period, factor basis, uncertainty and review status beside the figure. For public wording, ask the responsible reviewer to assess the precise claim against the evidence for that product, scope and audience. Record any independent assurance that actually covers the proposed use. A review of the supplier's blank record has a particular scope, and later decoration or distribution needs its own evidence.

In the fictional order, label 463.00 kg CO2e as the subtotal for the listed stages and 1.93 kg CO2e as the rounded average per accepted delivered tote. Carry the destination split, source assumptions and exclusions with those figures. Do not make the number stand for a measured lifecycle result or a verified comparison. Keep the wording of any proposed public statement with the evidence supporting it and confirm the relevant market requirements separately.

Keep the order evidence with the SKU

Keep the supplier value and the order records connected through the exact SKU and revision. The blank result needs its BOM, site, boundary, factor basis and review status. The order adds artwork and decoration records, input and accepted counts, packing and freight. Link them at the actual handover point so someone can check which stages belong to which record.

When a supplier changes the material or receiving boundary, record the revision and review the effect on the order subtotal. When the artwork or quantities change, revisit setup, consumables, rejects and how fixed activities are spread across accepted output. A destination change can alter both the number of packs and the transport basis.

Give each unresolved input a named owner. The purchaser can request a revised scope from the blank supplier, the decorator can confirm which meter interval belongs to setup, and the freight owner can confirm the route basis. Keep the method and review status visible when the figures are passed to finance or a campaign team. That handover makes it possible to update the estimate from evidence rather than replacing a number without context.

A repeatable decision for the next campaign

Build the next merchandise decision around a named order and a boundary that matches its purpose. Put the order total and the accepted-unit average next to the count and route evidence. A changed quantity, delivery split or product revision should lead back to the affected rows.

  • Record the SKU revision, expected function, accepted quantity and destinations.
  • Mark the supplier stages already included and the incremental decoration, waste, packing and fulfilment stages.
  • Reconcile the input, accepted and rejected counts. Record the subtotal, denominator, exclusions and any missing stage.
  • Name the decision owner and the evidence required to compare arrangements or approve a new use of the result.

For the fictional Seabank order, keep Arrangement A's subtotal available for the defined screening decision and leave the ranking open while B's inbound leg is missing. If a wider product footprint or public comparison is needed, agree on the additional scope and review. The decision record should make it clear which question the current result can answer.