Three separate panels distinguish buying credits, a public claim and derivatives. Each needs its actor, jurisdiction and evidence.
Identify the activity before deciding which evidence and authority apply.
Diagram text description

Three panels show Buy credits with Transaction, Public claim with Exact wording, and Derivatives with Exchange file. A shared line asks for Actor, Jurisdiction and Evidence. The panels do not show a sequence of approvals or certify any actual transaction or claim.

The voluntary carbon market involves several kinds of rules, each answering a different question. Choosing to buy credits voluntarily does not settle the law governing a transaction, a public environmental claim or the listing of a derivative. Start by identifying the actor, jurisdiction, instrument and intended use.

This guide uses dated US sources to explain those distinctions: an annual edition of the Federal Trade Commission’s Green Guides and the Federal Register notice withdrawing specific derivatives guidance. It also distinguishes private crediting and integrity processes, with a short, attributed European contrast. It does not establish every applicable rule in November 2026.

The practical question is therefore more precise than whether the whole market is regulated. What are you planning to do, and which record can support that decision? The fictional files later in the guide show how procurement, marketing and an exchange can hold different unresolved questions even when each activity concerns carbon credits.

Voluntary participation describes the choice to pursue an objective, such as financing mitigation through a credit purchase. Discharging a mandatory obligation requires identifying the particular legal programme and the instruments it accepts. A credit offered for voluntary use cannot simply be assumed eligible for every compliance purpose.

Intended useWhat must be identifiedWhat cannot be assumed
Voluntary objectiveBuyer’s objective, programme, units and proposed useExemption from other applicable law
Mandatory obligationSpecific legal programme and instruments it acceptsAcceptance of every voluntary credit

Table 1, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Intended use
Voluntary objective
What must be identified
Buyer’s objective, programme, units and proposed use
What cannot be assumed
Exemption from other applicable law

Row 2

Intended use
Mandatory obligation
What must be identified
Specific legal programme and instruments it accepts
What cannot be assumed
Acceptance of every voluntary credit

Keep the intended activity visible from the start. Procurement may be considering a spot purchase of issued units. Marketing may want to describe a product’s environmental impact. An exchange may be considering a contract whose underlying interest concerns voluntary carbon credits. Those activities call for different evidence and responsible reviewers.

The planned activity branches into buying spot units, making a public claim, or listing a derivative. Each branch needs its own evidence review.
Start with the planned activity, then identify its own evidence and reviewer.
Diagram text description

A starting question separates three activities. Buying spot units leads to transaction and programme records. Making a public claim leads to the exact wording and substantiation file. Listing a derivative leads to the exchange listing framework. The branches do not give approval to any activity.

For a purchase, request the programme and unit records, transaction terms and intended use. For a public claim, preserve the actual wording, audience and substantiation. For a derivative listing, identify the exchange, instrument and relevant listing framework. Completing one file does not answer the questions in the others.

This distinction also helps when someone describes credits as “voluntary” to explain why fewer checks are needed. The description alone establishes neither exemption from applicable law nor permission to use a particular label. Ask which obligation is supposedly being satisfied, where it arises and what establishes eligibility. If the team cannot identify the obligation, record the purchase objective without presenting it as compliance with an unnamed requirement.

Separate public law, guidance and private standards

Identify what authority a document has before relying on its conclusion. Legislation and implementing rules, an agency’s interpretation, a crediting programme’s procedures and a private integrity assessment can all matter to a decision. They do not carry interchangeable legal force.

The Green Guides edition discussed here explains that the Guides express FTC views and do not bind the Commission or the public. It also explains the relationship to enforcement under section 5 of the FTC Act. Similarly, the 2025 derivatives notice describes the withdrawn guidance as nonbinding while referring to an existing statutory and regulatory listing framework.

Evidence layerWhat to identifyLimit of the conclusion
Legislation and implementing rulesApplicable jurisdiction, actor and activityScope must be established for the actual case
Agency guidanceIssuer, date and stated interpretive statusGuidance is not automatically a new legal obligation
Crediting-programme rulesProgramme, method and relevant unit processProgramme records do not approve every public claim
Private integrity assessmentAssessed programme and credit categoryA quality assessment is not statutory permission

Table 2, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Evidence layer
Legislation and implementing rules
What to identify
Applicable jurisdiction, actor and activity
Limit of the conclusion
Scope must be established for the actual case

Row 2

Evidence layer
Agency guidance
What to identify
Issuer, date and stated interpretive status
Limit of the conclusion
Guidance is not automatically a new legal obligation

Row 3

Evidence layer
Crediting-programme rules
What to identify
Programme, method and relevant unit process
Limit of the conclusion
Programme records do not approve every public claim

Row 4

Evidence layer
Private integrity assessment
What to identify
Assessed programme and credit category
Limit of the conclusion
A quality assessment is not statutory permission

ICVCM describes two assessments: whether a programme is CCP-Eligible and whether a category of credits is CCP-Approved. A programme’s eligibility does not establish approval for all its categories. Its assessment process concerns private integrity criteria, rather than the legal review of a particular transaction or advertisement.

A buyer reviewing an offer should therefore identify both the programme and category behind any CCP reference. This guide provides no live eligibility list. Keep the actual assessment evidence beside the proposed use, with any category mismatch or missing status left open for review.

What verification, issuance and retirement establish

Verra’s FAQ describes distinct events in its own programme. Design validation concerns the project’s design; verification concerns reported reductions or removals for a monitored period. Issuance creates credits for trading, with serial numbers in a registry. Retirement removes units from circulation when used as offsets.

These events help explain which record to request. They should not be compressed into a single statement that a project or buyer has been “approved”.

Event or activityRelevant evidenceQuestion still separate
Design validationProject design and validation materialWhat results were subsequently monitored?
Result verificationMonitoring and verification reportsWhich units were actually issued?
IssuanceRegistry quantity and serial identityWhich units are offered to this buyer?
Purchase and transferTransaction and matched unit recordsHas retirement occurred for the intended beneficiary?
RetirementRegistry status and retirement detailsWhat public wording can the buyer substantiate?

Table 3, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Event or activity
Design validation
Relevant evidence
Project design and validation material
Question still separate
What results were subsequently monitored?

Row 2

Event or activity
Result verification
Relevant evidence
Monitoring and verification reports
Question still separate
Which units were actually issued?

Row 3

Event or activity
Issuance
Relevant evidence
Registry quantity and serial identity
Question still separate
Which units are offered to this buyer?

Row 4

Event or activity
Purchase and transfer
Relevant evidence
Transaction and matched unit records
Question still separate
Has retirement occurred for the intended beneficiary?

Row 5

Event or activity
Retirement
Relevant evidence
Registry status and retirement details
Question still separate
What public wording can the buyer substantiate?

A purchase can occur before the buyer has evidence of transfer or retirement. Request the records for the same units and quantity, rather than treating an invoice as the final registry event. A retirement record can then help establish what happened to those units.

The programme explanation does not provide a universal assurance about title, current eligibility or every project’s quality. Nor does retirement decide the lawfulness of an advertisement. Keep those limits attached to the record: the next reviewer needs to know whether the open question concerns the units, the transaction or the words proposed for publication.

Check the proposed claim, not just the credit

A claim review begins with the exact words and the impression they convey. The Green Guides in the GPO annual edition revised 1 January 2026 address both express and implied environmental marketing claims. Section 260.2 explains that marketers need support for the reasonable interpretations their advertising communicates before making the claim.

For carbon offsets, section 260.5 discusses reliable scientific and accounting methods for quantification and preventing the same reduction from being sold more than once. It also addresses timing: reductions that will not occur for two years or longer require clear and prominent disclosure to avoid the misleading timing impression described in the Guides. Reductions, or the activities causing them, required by law raise another stated limitation.

Certification does not remove the substantiation task. Section 260.6 explains that a marketer must support the claims reasonably communicated by a certification, and that the basis of an environmental seal matters. A registry retirement entry and a certification logo therefore cannot substitute for the entire claims file.

Consider the explicitly fictional proposed phrase “This product is carbon neutral”. The reviewer needs the complete artwork and context, the product and period addressed, the emissions basis and evidence supporting the offset-related messages. The task is to identify what the wording communicates and what remains unsupported; this example does not approve it.

The source used here is an annual edition, not proof that every later amendment or applicable state or local rule has been checked. Preserve that date limit when passing the wording to the responsible claims reviewer.

What the 2025 US derivatives-guidance withdrawal changed

The CFTC withdrew its 2024 voluntary-carbon-credit derivatives-listing guidance effective 10 September 2025. The notice was published on 15 September 2025 in the Federal Register, at 90 FR 44321–44322. The effective date and publication date describe different events and should be recorded separately.

The notice says that section 5c of the Commodity Exchange Act and Commission regulations in parts 38 and 40 already provide the framework for listing these derivatives contracts. It characterises the withdrawn guidance as nonbinding and says it created no new compliance obligations or product-listing standards for designated contract markets.

The withdrawal took effect on 10 September 2025. The Federal Register notice was published on 15 September 2025. The existing listing framework remained.
The 2025 notice gives different effective and publication dates for the guidance withdrawal.
Diagram text description

A timeline connects the withdrawal effective date of 10 September 2025 to publication of the notice on 15 September 2025. A separate note records that the notice retained the existing listing framework. This is a dated account of that notice, not a current review of every legal requirement.

Withdrawal consequently did not abolish the underlying listing framework described in that notice. An exchange examining a voluntary-carbon-credit derivative still needs to identify the applicable listing requirements. Reading “guidance withdrawn” as “no listing rules” would reverse the notice’s explanation.

Keep the actor and instrument clear. This document addresses designated contract markets and derivative contracts. A business purchasing spot credits is a different file; the notice does not by itself resolve every legal question about that purchase.

The evidence supports this narrow, dated account of the withdrawal. It does not establish a comprehensive current review of the Commodity Exchange Act, spot-market jurisdiction, intermediaries or enforcement. An exchange reviewer should obtain the applicable listing materials for its actual contract and date rather than extending the notice beyond its stated subject.

Fix the jurisdiction, instrument and source date

Jurisdiction and source status can change the question that remains open. The US examples above do not form a worldwide compliance checklist. Even within a jurisdiction, the answer depends on the instrument and whether the statement concerns a product, a company or financing an environmental initiative.

A September 2026 European Commission services FAQ offers a useful contrast. In question 10, the services discuss the restriction on product claims of neutral, reduced or positive greenhouse-gas impact when based on offsetting. They distinguish those claims from company-level statements, which remain subject to other relevant provisions, and from communicating environmental investments transparently without misleading consumers.

Attribute that distinction carefully. The document expressly describes preliminary services views, says they are not an official Commission position and reserves authoritative interpretation of EU law to the Court of Justice. It does not establish the national transposition position or approve a proposed label in a particular country.

A claims file intended for more than one market should therefore record the audience and publication jurisdiction alongside the precise wording. Ask the responsible reviewer to establish the applicable national law, dates and scope for each intended use. Changing a product claim into a financing statement is not, by itself, evidence that the revised wording is acceptable.

The practical limit is straightforward: a source may explain a distinction while leaving its application to the actual statement unresolved.

Work through three fictional activity files

These three activity files are explicitly fictional teaching examples. Their documents, roles and proposed actions are invented to show how a review can remain unresolved. They are not real customer cases, mandated forms or legal outcomes.

Fictional actor and activityJurisdiction assumptionEvidence presentMissing evidenceResponsible ownerUnresolved question
Procurement: proposed spot-credit purchaseUS buyer; no mandatory programme identifiedSeller offer naming a programme and quantityMatched serials, transfer terms and intended-use checksProcurement lead and transaction reviewerWhat exactly is being acquired and for which use?
Marketing: proposed product-neutral claimStatement intended for US customersDraft artwork and a retirement screenshotComplete product basis and substantiation for implied messagesMarketing lead and claims reviewerWhat does the wording communicate, and is each message supported?
Exchange: proposed credit derivative listingUS designated contract market assumedContract concept and 2025 withdrawal noticeActual listing submission and applicable framework analysisExchange listing and legal reviewersHow do the retained requirements apply to this contract?

Table 4, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Fictional actor and activity
Procurement: proposed spot-credit purchase
Jurisdiction assumption
US buyer; no mandatory programme identified
Evidence present
Seller offer naming a programme and quantity
Missing evidence
Matched serials, transfer terms and intended-use checks
Responsible owner
Procurement lead and transaction reviewer
Unresolved question
What exactly is being acquired and for which use?

Row 2

Fictional actor and activity
Marketing: proposed product-neutral claim
Jurisdiction assumption
Statement intended for US customers
Evidence present
Draft artwork and a retirement screenshot
Missing evidence
Complete product basis and substantiation for implied messages
Responsible owner
Marketing lead and claims reviewer
Unresolved question
What does the wording communicate, and is each message supported?

Row 3

Fictional actor and activity
Exchange: proposed credit derivative listing
Jurisdiction assumption
US designated contract market assumed
Evidence present
Contract concept and 2025 withdrawal notice
Missing evidence
Actual listing submission and applicable framework analysis
Responsible owner
Exchange listing and legal reviewers
Unresolved question
How do the retained requirements apply to this contract?

The procurement file concerns a possible transaction. It does not establish acceptance by an unnamed compliance programme. The marketing file contains evidence about retirement but leaves the product statement unsupported. The exchange file contains a relevant notice, while its actual listing analysis remains missing.

Each owner can now request something specific. Procurement asks for the unit and transaction records. Marketing obtains the full substantiation file and exact proposed presentation. The exchange reviewer obtains the contract-specific listing materials. No row moves automatically to approval because another row has a useful document.

Keep proposed action, available evidence and unresolved decision in separate fields. That separation makes the file useful when responsibility passes between teams and prevents a screenshot or general policy summary from becoming a substitute for the missing evidence.

Keep a source-status record with the decision

A source-status record explains why a document was used and what it leaves open. Keep edition, publication, effective and consultation dates separate. A recent download does not make an older annual edition a current-law survey.

The five external sources used here were consulted on 8 November 2026 (Asia/Shanghai). That records consultation of those documents; it does not certify every rule applicable on that date.

Publisher and source typeDate establishedScope used hereOpen question
CFTC: Federal Register withdrawal noticePublished 15 September 2025; effective 10 September 2025Withdrawal of nonbinding derivatives guidance and retained listing frameworkRequirements for the actual exchange contract
FTC/GPO: annual Green Guides editionEdition revision: 1 January 2026Sections 260.1, 260.2, 260.5 and 260.6Later changes and applicability to the complete claim
Verra: programme FAQPublication/version date not establishedValidation, verification, issuance and retirement explanationsActual programme and unit records
ICVCM: private assessment explanationPublication/version date not establishedProgramme eligibility versus category approvalStatus relevant to the offered category
Commission services: preliminary FAQSeptember 2026 documentDisclaimer and question 10 distinctionRelevant national law and exact proposed wording

Table 5, shown one row at a time. Every field is retained.

Row 1

Publisher and source type
CFTC: Federal Register withdrawal notice
Date established
Published 15 September 2025; effective 10 September 2025
Scope used here
Withdrawal of nonbinding derivatives guidance and retained listing framework
Open question
Requirements for the actual exchange contract

Row 2

Publisher and source type
FTC/GPO: annual Green Guides edition
Date established
Edition revision: 1 January 2026
Scope used here
Sections 260.1, 260.2, 260.5 and 260.6
Open question
Later changes and applicability to the complete claim

Row 3

Publisher and source type
Verra: programme FAQ
Date established
Publication/version date not established
Scope used here
Validation, verification, issuance and retirement explanations
Open question
Actual programme and unit records

Row 4

Publisher and source type
ICVCM: private assessment explanation
Date established
Publication/version date not established
Scope used here
Programme eligibility versus category approval
Open question
Status relevant to the offered category

Row 5

Publisher and source type
Commission services: preliminary FAQ
Date established
September 2026 document
Scope used here
Disclaimer and question 10 distinction
Open question
Relevant national law and exact proposed wording

This filled register performs a different job from the fictional activity matrix. The matrix assigns a decision to an owner; the register identifies the authority, date and limit behind the evidence that owner has received.

Retain unknown dates as unknown. A new programme rule, amended legal provision or fuller claims file could change the analysis. Record that missing item and who will obtain it, instead of updating a “checked” date while leaving the underlying question unanswered.

Assign the unresolved questions before acting

The fictional files can move forward through specific evidence requests. The procurement lead needs matched units, transaction terms and a defined intended use. The marketing lead needs the complete product basis and support for the messages conveyed by its proposed wording. The exchange reviewer needs the contract-specific listing analysis under the relevant framework.

The next decision

Keep the three decisions distinct. A programme assessment can help with a private integrity question; a retirement record can document a unit event; neither automatically resolves the public-claim file. Withdrawal of the dated derivatives guidance likewise does not clear the fictional exchange’s listing question.

Before acting, give each responsible reviewer the exact activity, assumed jurisdiction, source version and open document request. Record the response against that file so another team can see what was resolved and what remains outstanding. This guide supplies a way to organise the review; it does not decide a particular transaction, approve an advertisement or certify compliance.